Belcher J R, Rehahn M
Br J Dis Chest. 1979 Jan;73(1):18-30.
1267 patients who underwent surgical treatment for bronchial carcinoma during the period 1949--70 have been studied. 304 underwent thoracotomy without further resection; 88% died within 12 months; the maximum survival was 56 months. Of the remaining 963 patients, 869 late deaths are recorded, and the causes of these have been studied. The 5-year actuarial survival rate was 25.9%; the 10-year rate 15.3%; the 15-year rate 9.3%; and the 20-year rate 3.9%. 610 of the 869 deaths were due to bronchial carcinoma; 79 were due to respiratory disease; 57 to coronary disease; and 23 to other neoplasms. The percentage of total deaths due to bronchial carcinoma declined with the passage of time. It was 86.5% during the first year; 79.2% during the next 4 years; 53.7% from 5 to 10 years; and 39.3% over 10 years. The second commonest cause of death was respiratory disease, which tended to be related to the extent of resection. Compared with a population of the same age and sex structure, suffering the death rates of England and Wales during the period involved, these patients show a massive excess of deaths from bronchial carcinoma and a smaller excess from respiratory disease; and a considerable shortfall from coronary disease, other carcinomas, and all other causes. A more favourable probability of survival was linked with lobectomy, squamous cell type and the younger age group. A less favourable probability was linked with pneumonectomy, adenocarcinoma and older age-groups. There was no significant difference due to sex. After the first 2 years, with their heavy death rate, the chances of surviving to 10 years improved by about 15% each year.
对1949年至1970年间接受支气管癌手术治疗的1267例患者进行了研究。304例行开胸手术但未进一步切除;88%在12个月内死亡;最长存活时间为56个月。在其余963例患者中,记录了869例晚期死亡病例,并对其死因进行了研究。5年精算生存率为25.9%;10年生存率为15.3%;15年生存率为9.3%;20年生存率为3.9%。869例死亡病例中,610例死于支气管癌;79例死于呼吸系统疾病;57例死于冠心病;23例死于其他肿瘤。支气管癌导致的总死亡百分比随时间推移而下降。第一年为86.5%;接下来4年为79.2%;5至10年为53.7%;10年以上为39.3%。第二大常见死因是呼吸系统疾病,这往往与切除范围有关。与年龄和性别结构相同、处于相关时期英国和威尔士死亡率水平的人群相比,这些患者支气管癌导致的死亡人数大幅超标,呼吸系统疾病导致的死亡人数超标幅度较小;冠心病、其他癌症和所有其他原因导致的死亡人数则明显不足。更有利的生存概率与肺叶切除术、鳞状细胞类型和较年轻年龄组相关。不太有利的生存概率与全肺切除术、腺癌和较年长年龄组相关。性别方面无显著差异。在最初2年死亡率较高之后,存活至10年的几率每年提高约15%。