Stewart G T
J Epidemiol Community Health. 1979 Jun;33(2):150-6. doi: 10.1136/jech.33.2.150.
From a file of 1127 children in whom signs of brain damage were reported after injections of vaccines containing pertussis antigen, the first 197 cases with good documentation of events were chosen for further study. In these children, 291 reactions had been reported, usually of screaming attacks (68), convulsions (87), collapse (17), or one or more of these signs (99), within 24 hours of injection. Subsequently 165 children became mentally defective and 102 had further convulsions. In 129 (65%), contraindications to vaccination were present and in 25, subsequent injections were given despite reactions to a previous injection or injections. From a mathematical model constructed from data in published reports, it is calculated that the frequency of convulsions appears to be higher by 2: 1 in vaccinated than in unvaccinated infants. In children subject to febrile or other convulsions, the frequencies may be of the same order but a second convulsion occurring only after a second or subsequent injection of vaccine is unlikely to be due to chance. The pattern of reactions and sequence of events observed in the present study and in published reports suggest an association between certain reactions to pertussis vaccine and subsequent severe brain damage, the incidence of which appears to be not less than one per fifty thousand children vaccinated during the last 20 years of mass vaccination in the United Kingdom.
在一份1127名儿童的档案中,这些儿童在接种含有百日咳抗原的疫苗后出现了脑损伤迹象,从中选取了首批197例事件记录良好的病例进行进一步研究。在这些儿童中,有291次反应被报告,通常是在注射后24小时内出现尖叫发作(68例)、惊厥(87例)、虚脱(17例)或出现这些症状中的一种或多种(99例)。随后,165名儿童出现智力缺陷,102名儿童再次惊厥。129名儿童(65%)存在接种禁忌,25名儿童尽管之前注射疫苗有反应,但仍进行了后续注射。根据已发表报告中的数据构建的数学模型计算得出,接种疫苗的婴儿惊厥发生率似乎比未接种疫苗的婴儿高2倍。在易发生发热性惊厥或其他惊厥的儿童中,发生率可能处于同一水平,但仅在第二次或后续接种疫苗后才发生的第二次惊厥不太可能是偶然现象。本研究及已发表报告中观察到的反应模式和事件顺序表明,百日咳疫苗的某些反应与随后的严重脑损伤之间存在关联,在英国过去20年大规模接种疫苗期间,其发生率似乎不少于每万名接种儿童中有一例。