Toyota S
Sangyo Igaku. 1979 Jul;21(4):335-48. doi: 10.1539/joh1959.21.335.
The behavior of fluoride ion level in the urine and in the serum was measured as an index for health care of workers exposed to hydrofluoric acid, the effect of fluorine-containing foodstuff intake by the workers being considered at the same time. For this study, 250 hydrofluoric acid workers and as a control group 1,600 non-hydrofluoric-acid workers were examined. All workers, ranging in age from 15 to 59 years old, came from the same electronics factory. Fluorides in the biological fluids were measured by using the fluoride ion-specific electrode method and the electrode potential recording method concurrently. The fluoride ion levels (geometric mean) in the urine and in the serum of the non-hydrofluoric-acid workers were determined to be 0.59 ppm and 12 ppb, respectively. Among the influences of fluorine-containing foodstuff on fluoride content in the biological fluids, the effect of black tea and/or green tea intake was particularly remarkable. In the case of the non-hydrofluoric-acid workers, the concentration increased to about double of the control value. Similarly in a diet test on volunteers, the concentration increased about six times. As for the response to tea intake with the lapse of time, the concentration in the urine specimen (spot urine, S.G. corrected: 1.024) reached the maximum value three hours after the intake. In the case of the serum specimen, the maximum value was recorded one hour after the intake, and the influence of the intake continued for several hours. These results suggest that, in the medical examination of hydrofluroic acid workers, restriction of intake of tea and in some cases even a fasting program would have to be introduced as necessary pre-conditions. Upon observation of fluorine concentration in the urine with the lapse of time of hydrofluoric acid workers restricting tea intake, it was confirmed that the trend of the day-to-day variation was small. But that of the in-a-day variation, namely, an increase in the concentration toward the end of daily working hours was obvious. By introduction of these well-regulated methods, it has become possible to properly evaluate even the influence of hydrofluoric acid on the workers irregularly exposed to a hydrofluoric acid environment having a lower concentration than that of the threshold limit value (3 ppm). However, in view of ease of collection and measurement of specimens, speed, and degree of response to the exposure, it can be concluded that the measurement of fluorine content in the urine is more advantageous as an index for the health care than that in the serum. For this reason it is desirable that the former method should be given priority from the view point of prevailing industrial hygiene laws and regulations.
测量尿液和血清中氟离子水平的变化,以此作为接触氢氟酸工人健康状况的指标,同时考虑工人摄入含氟食物的影响。本研究对250名氢氟酸作业工人和作为对照组的1600名非氢氟酸作业工人进行了检查。所有工人年龄在15至59岁之间,均来自同一家电子厂。采用氟离子特异性电极法和电极电位记录法同时测量生物体液中的氟化物。非氢氟酸作业工人尿液和血清中的氟离子水平(几何平均值)分别确定为0.59 ppm和12 ppb。在含氟食物对生物体液中氟含量的影响中,摄入红茶和/或绿茶的影响尤为显著。对于非氢氟酸作业工人,浓度增加到对照值的约两倍。同样,在对志愿者的饮食测试中,浓度增加了约六倍。至于随时间推移对饮茶的反应,尿液标本(晨尿,比重校正:1.024)中的浓度在摄入后三小时达到最大值。对于血清标本,最大值在摄入后一小时记录,摄入的影响持续数小时。这些结果表明,在对氢氟酸作业工人进行医学检查时,必须将限制饮茶以及在某些情况下甚至禁食作为必要的前提条件。观察限制饮茶的氢氟酸作业工人尿液中氟浓度随时间的变化,证实每日变化趋势较小。但日内变化趋势,即浓度在每日工作时间结束时升高是明显的。通过引入这些规范的方法,即使对于不定期接触浓度低于阈限值(3 ppm)的氢氟酸环境的工人,也能够正确评估氢氟酸对他们的影响。然而,考虑到标本采集和测量的便利性、速度以及对接触的反应程度,可以得出结论,作为健康状况指标,测量尿液中的氟含量比测量血清中的氟含量更具优势。因此,从现行工业卫生法律法规的角度来看,优先采用前一种方法是可取的。