Lilly H A, Lowbury E J
Br Med J. 1971 Sep 18;3(5776):674-6. doi: 10.1136/bmj.3.5776.674.
Repeated hand washing with a detergent solution containing 0.75% chlorhexidine digluconate was found to cause a large reduction in the resident skin flora which was slightly though significantly smaller than that caused by the use of 3% hexachlorophane liquid soap containing a phenolic preservative, chlorocresol 0.3%. Both agents caused a greater immediate reduction of bacteria after a single hand washing than the hexachlorophane liquid soap without a phenolic additive had shown in earlier experiments; the soap base containing chlorocresol 0.3% but no hexachlorophane was also found to cause a large reduction in skin flora. The chlorhexidine detergent solution had no residual disinfectant action on the skin after rinsing and drying the hands.Disinfection of an operation site for two minutes with povidone-iodine containing 1% available iodine in 70% ethyl alcohol caused about as great a reduction in resident flora as a similar treatment with alcoholic 0.5% chlorhexidine. Both treatments were more effective than disinfection with aqueous 1% cetrimide or 0.1% benzalkonium chloride solutions.
研究发现,用含有0.75%葡萄糖酸洗必泰的洗涤剂溶液反复洗手,可使常驻皮肤菌群大幅减少,虽然比使用含0.3%氯甲酚(一种酚类防腐剂)的3%六氯酚液体皂所导致的减少幅度略小,但仍具有显著差异。与早期实验中不含酚类添加剂的六氯酚液体皂相比,这两种制剂单次洗手后对细菌的即时减少效果都更显著;还发现含0.3%氯甲酚但不含六氯酚的皂基也可使皮肤菌群大幅减少。洗手并擦干后,洗必泰洗涤剂溶液对皮肤没有残留消毒作用。用含1%有效碘的聚维酮碘在70%乙醇中对手术部位消毒两分钟,对常驻菌群的减少效果与用0.5%酒精洗必泰进行类似处理大致相同。这两种处理都比用1%西曲溴铵水溶液或0.1%苯扎氯铵溶液消毒更有效。