Ney D, Hollingsworth D R, Cousins L
Diabetes Care. 1982 Sep-Oct;5(5):529-33. doi: 10.2337/diacare.5.5.529.
Five quantitative measures of diabetic control [HbA1c determinations, mean 24-h plasma glucose values, mean amplitude of glycemic excursions (MAGE), mean 24-h urinary loss of glucose, and daily exogenous insulin requirement] were compared in 20 pregnant women who were randomly assigned to either a high-carbohydrate, high-fiber diet (HCF) that was low in fat or to a control diet commonly prescribed for pregnancy. Eleven women followed the HCF diet and nine subjects, the control diet, from baseline entry into the study until delivery. Dietary compliance was excellent, with 78% of the women in each group rated good or acceptable. HbA1c values were similar in both groups at baseline (HCF: 11.0 +/- 0.5% versus control: 10.2 +/- 0.6%), with no different predelivery values (8.6 +/- 0.4%). Mean 24-h plasma glucose levels improved in patients on both diets, with lower values noted in the HCF group at predelivery. MAGE values and standard deviations did not differ significantly in the two groups. Glycosuria decreased markedly in both dietary groups, but differences between groups were not significant. Improved control of diabetes on the HCF diet was achieved with significantly lower increments in insulin dose during gestation (HCF baseline: 32 +/- 8 U/24 h to 66 +/- 10 U/24 h versus control baseline: 27 +/- 9 U/24 h to 108 +/- 12 U/24 h, P less than 0.03). Outcome of pregnancy did not differ in the two groups of patients, but women on the HCF diet gained less weight than those on the control diet (26 +/- 3 lb versus 35 +/- 5 lb, P less than 0.05). Mean newborn gestational age was similar in the two groups (HCF: 37.2 +/- 0.7 wk versus control: 36.5 +/- 0.7 wk). Mean birth weight in infants of HCF mothers was 3809 +/- 248 g versus 3313 +/- 278 g in infants of control mothers (P less than 0.05). We conclude that although marked improvement of diabetic control occurred on both regimens, patients on the HCF diet achieved better control of diabetes with significantly lower increments in exogenous insulin.
对20名孕妇的五项糖尿病控制定量指标[糖化血红蛋白(HbA1c)测定值、24小时平均血糖值、血糖波动幅度均值(MAGE)、24小时尿糖丢失均值以及每日外源性胰岛素需求量]进行了比较。这些孕妇被随机分为两组,一组采用高脂肪低碳水化合物、高纤维饮食(HCF),另一组采用通常为孕妇开具的对照饮食。从进入研究的基线期直至分娩,11名女性遵循HCF饮食,9名受试者遵循对照饮食。饮食依从性良好,每组中78%的女性被评为良好或可接受。两组在基线时的HbA1c值相似(HCF组:11.0±0.5%,对照组:10.2±0.6%),分娩前的值无差异(8.6±0.4%)。两种饮食的患者24小时平均血糖水平均有所改善,HCF组在分娩前的值较低。两组的MAGE值和标准差无显著差异。两组饮食组的糖尿均显著减少,但组间差异不显著。HCF饮食组在妊娠期胰岛素剂量增加显著较低的情况下实现了对糖尿病的更好控制(HCF组基线:32±8 U/24小时至66±10 U/24小时,对照组基线:27±9 U/24小时至108±12 U/24小时,P<0.03)。两组患者的妊娠结局无差异,但HCF饮食组的女性体重增加少于对照饮食组(26±3磅对35±5磅,P<0.05)。两组的新生儿平均胎龄相似(HCF组:37.2±0.7周,对照组:36.5±0.7周)。HCF组母亲的婴儿平均出生体重为3809±248克,而对照组母亲的婴儿为3313±278克(P<0.05)。我们得出结论,虽然两种方案均使糖尿病控制有显著改善,但HCF饮食组患者通过显著较低的外源性胰岛素增量实现了对糖尿病的更好控制。