Fine P E, Clarkson J A
Int J Epidemiol. 1983 Sep;12(3):332-9. doi: 10.1093/ije/12.3.332.
Published predictions of the impact which different levels of vaccination should have on measles incidence are discussed in the context of observed data on vaccine uptake and measles incidence in England and Wales. Discrepancies are noted between prediction and observation with regard to the effect of vaccination on epidemic periodicity, epidemic size, age distribution of cases, and the disappearance of measles from communities. These errors are attributable to failures to recognize the implications of seasonal trends in incidence, age dependence of risk, and the non-homogeneity of human populations. Predictive models are useful hypotheses, but should be assessed critically against observation.
结合英格兰和威尔士疫苗接种率及麻疹发病率的观测数据,讨论了已发表的关于不同疫苗接种水平对麻疹发病率影响的预测。在疫苗接种对流行周期、流行规模、病例年龄分布以及麻疹在社区中消失的影响方面,预测与观测结果存在差异。这些误差归因于未能认识到发病率季节性趋势的影响、风险的年龄依赖性以及人群的非均质性。预测模型是有用的假设,但应根据观测结果进行严格评估。