Sato K, Matsumiya H, Saito A
Jpn J Antibiot. 1982 May;35(5):1240-8.
Antimicrobial activities of 3 aminoglycoside antibiotics, including gentamicin (GM), amikacin (AMK) and tobramycin (TOB), were determined against 1,714 Pseudomonas aeruginosa strains isolated from clinical specimens in this hospital during 3 years since April of 1976 to March of 1979. From these results, some discussions were made as follows. 1) MIC ranges, to which about 70% of strains tested distributed, were 3.13--6.25 micrograms/ml of GM, 3.13--12.5 micrograms/ml of AMK, and 0.78--3.13 micrograms/ml of TOB in each year. 2) Frequency of drug-resistant strain, which showed 12.5 micrograms/ml or more MIC value in any drug, was highest in AMK and lowest in TOB in each year. 3) Drug-resistant strain-frequency to any one of 3 drugs tested was lowest in 1977, and higher in 1976 than in 1978. It was not supposed that this phenomenon should be undoubtedly caused by the amount of drugs used in each year in this hospital. 4) Frequency of highly TOB-resistant strain increased year by year during the period studied, unlike both cases of other 2 antibiotics. 5) Cross resistance was most frequently observed between GM and TOB, and more between GM and AMK than between TOB and AMK. 6) It was considered that anti- Ps. aeruginosa-activity was highest in TOB followed by GM and by AMK. 7) It was suggested that there seemed to be some qualitative difference between antimicrobial activity of AMK and those of GM and TOB.
测定了1976年4月至1979年3月这3年间从本院临床标本中分离出的1714株铜绿假单胞菌对3种氨基糖苷类抗生素(庆大霉素(GM)、阿米卡星(AMK)和妥布霉素(TOB))的抗菌活性。根据这些结果,进行了如下讨论。1)每年约70%受试菌株分布的MIC范围为:GM为3.13 - 6.25微克/毫升,AMK为3.13 - 12.5微克/毫升,TOB为0.78 - 3.13微克/毫升。2)每年对任何一种药物MIC值显示为12.5微克/毫升或更高的耐药菌株频率,在AMK中最高,在TOB中最低。3)对所测试的3种药物中任何一种的耐药菌株频率在1977年最低,1976年高于1978年。认为这种现象不应无疑地由本院每年使用的药物量引起。4)在所研究期间,与其他两种抗生素的情况不同,高度耐TOB菌株的频率逐年增加。5)GM和TOB之间最常观察到交叉耐药,GM和AMK之间的交叉耐药比TOB和AMK之间更多。6)认为抗铜绿假单胞菌活性在TOB中最高,其次是GM和AMK。7)提示AMK的抗菌活性与GM和TOB的抗菌活性之间似乎存在一些质的差异。