Panush R S, Carter R L, Katz P, Kowsari B, Longley S, Finnie S
Arthritis Rheum. 1983 Apr;26(4):462-71. doi: 10.1002/art.1780260403.
Although diet therapy for arthritis has received considerable publicity, there is little objective information about its efficacy. We undertook a 10-week, controlled, double-blind, randomized trial of patients with active rheumatoid arthritis (RA). Twenty-six patients completed the study; 11 were on an experimental diet (a specific popular diet free of additives, preservatives, fruit, red meat, herbs, and dairy products) and 15 were on a "placebo" diet. Of 183 variables analyzed, there were no clinically important differences among rheumatologic, laboratory, immunologic, radiologic, or nutritional findings between patients on experimental and placebo diets. Six RA patients on the placebo and 5 on the experimental diet improved by objective criteria. Improvement averaged 29% for patients on placebo and 32% for patients on experimental diets. Two patients on the experimental diet improved notably, elected to remain on the experimental diet following the study period, have continued to improve, and noted exacerbations of disease upon consuming nonexperimental diet foods. Our study failed to provide evidence of objective overall clinical benefit of this diet as followed by a group of patients with longstanding, progressive, active RA. However, our data are not inconsistent with the possibility that individualized dietary manipulations might be beneficial for selected patients with rheumatic disease.
尽管关节炎饮食疗法已受到广泛关注,但关于其疗效的客观信息却很少。我们对活动性类风湿关节炎(RA)患者进行了一项为期10周的对照、双盲、随机试验。26名患者完成了研究;11名患者采用实验性饮食(一种不含添加剂、防腐剂、水果、红肉、草药和乳制品的特定流行饮食),15名患者采用“安慰剂”饮食。在分析的183个变量中,采用实验性饮食和安慰剂饮食的患者在风湿病学、实验室检查、免疫学、放射学或营养方面的结果没有临床上的重要差异。按照客观标准,安慰剂组的6名RA患者和实验性饮食组的5名患者病情有所改善。安慰剂组患者的改善平均为29%,实验性饮食组患者为32%。实验性饮食组的两名患者改善显著,在研究期后选择继续采用实验性饮食,病情持续改善,并且在食用非实验性饮食食物后病情出现加重。我们的研究未能提供证据表明这种饮食对一组患有长期、进行性、活动性RA的患者具有客观的总体临床益处。然而,我们的数据与个体化饮食调整可能对某些风湿病患者有益的可能性并不矛盾。