Doll R, Peto R
J Epidemiol Community Health (1978). 1978 Dec;32(4):303-13. doi: 10.1136/jech.32.4.303.
In a 20-year prospective study on British doctors, smoking habits were ascertained by questionnaire and lung cancer incidence was monitored. Among cigarette smokers who started smoking at ages 16-25 and who smoked 40 or less per day, the annual lung cancer incidence in the age range 40-79 was:0.273X10(-12). (cigarettes/day+6)2. (age--22.5)4.5. The form of the dependence on dose in this relationship is subject not only to random error but also to serious systematic biases, which are discussed. However, there was certainly some statistically significant (P less than 0.01) upward curvature of the dose-response relationship in the range 0-40 cigarettes/day, which is what might be expected if more that one of the "stages" (in the multistage genesis of bronchial carcinoma) was strongly affected by smoking. If a higher than linear dose-response relationship exists between dose per bronchial cell and age-specific risk per bronchial cell, this may help explain why bronchial carcinomas chiefly arise in the upper bronchi, for dilution effects might then protect the larger areas lower in the bronchial tree.
在一项针对英国医生的20年前瞻性研究中,通过问卷调查确定吸烟习惯,并监测肺癌发病率。在16 - 25岁开始吸烟且每天吸烟40支及以下的吸烟者中,40 - 79岁年龄段的肺癌年发病率为:0.273×10⁻¹²·(每天吸烟支数 + 6)²·(年龄 - 22.5)⁴·⁵。这种关系中对剂量的依赖形式不仅受到随机误差的影响,还受到严重的系统偏差影响,对此进行了讨论。然而,在每天0 - 40支香烟的范围内,剂量 - 反应关系肯定存在一些具有统计学意义(P小于0.01)的向上弯曲,这是如果支气管癌多阶段发生过程中的不止一个“阶段”受到吸烟的强烈影响时可能预期的情况。如果每个支气管细胞的剂量与每个支气管细胞的年龄特异性风险之间存在高于线性的剂量 - 反应关系,这可能有助于解释为什么支气管癌主要发生在上叶支气管,因为稀释效应可能会保护支气管树下部的较大区域。