Speicher A, Jessberger J, Braun R, Hollnberger H, Stigler F, Manz R
Abteilung für Anästhesie und Intensivmedizin, Krankenhaus der Barmherzigen Brüder, Regensburg.
Anaesthesist. 1995 Apr;44(4):265-73. doi: 10.1007/s001010050153.
After lung resection, early extubation and the rapid return of the patients ability to cooperate is the predominant goal. Propofol anaesthesia is characterised by rapid awakening and recovery of cognitive and psychomotor functions and is consequently desirable for such operations. Experience so far in lung surgery, however, is limited. Besides the level of consciousness we investigated various spirometric parameters after lung resection. Total intravenous anaesthesia was performed with propofol, while balanced anaesthesia was performed with isoflurane. METHODS. A total of 93 patients evaluated electively for wedge excision or lobectomy were enrolled in an open, prospective, randomised, interindividual comparative study. Sixty-three patients could be evaluated with complete data sets. In the evening and the morning before the operation the patients were premedicated orally with clorazepate 0.5-0.7 mg/kg. Anaesthesia was induced in group 1 with propofol (1.0-2.5 mg/kg) and maintained with propofol (4-12 mg/kg) in 50% O2/air. The patients in group 2 received methohexital (1-2 mg/kg) for induction and isoflurane (0.4-2.0 vol%) in 50% O2/air for the maintenance of general anaesthesia. In both groups analgesia was achieved by using fentanyl (up to 10 micrograms/kg) and muscle relaxation by using atracurium. Psychomotor tests (minimal mental state, reaction time) were performed the day before the operation (t1), immediately prior to induction of anaesthesia (t2) and 5 min, 30 min, 60 min, 90 min, 24 h, and 7 days after extubation (t3-t8). Spirometry (forced expiratory volume in 1 s, FEV1; forced vital capacity, FVC; peak expiratory flow, PEF) was carried out at times t1, t2 and t5-t8. RESULTS. The two groups were comparable regarding preoperative status (age, sex, preoperative risk score, psychomotor tests, and spirometric values) and the operation performed (wedge excision/lobectomy, duration of anaesthesia). The extubation time was slightly shorter in the propofol group (18 +/- 8 min) than in the isoflurane group (20 +/- 6 min). Also, the results of the psychomotor tests were somewhat better in the propofol group than those in the isoflurane group. The clearest differences were found in the early postoperative period, but not all differences were significant. Statistically highly significant differences between the two groups were found for the three spirometric parameters. Based on the FEV1 value of the 7th postoperative day, FEV1 taken 60 min after extubation declined by 27.9% in the propofol group vs. 51.7% in the isoflurane group (P = 0.01). At 90 min after extubation the corresponding decline in the propofol group was 26.6%, in the isoflurane group 51.1% (P = 0.003). In addition, the decline of FVC and PEF measured 60 min and 90 min after extubation was significantly smaller in the propofol group than in the isoflurane group. CONCLUSION. The postoperative impairment of lung function after lung resection under propofol anaesthesia is statistically significantly smaller than under isoflurane anaesthesia. Total intravenous anaesthesia with propofol is particularly suitable for this kind of operation.
肺切除术后,尽早拔管并使患者迅速恢复合作能力是主要目标。丙泊酚麻醉的特点是苏醒迅速,认知和精神运动功能恢复快,因此适用于此类手术。然而,目前肺手术方面的经验有限。除了意识水平,我们还研究了肺切除术后的各种肺功能参数。采用丙泊酚进行全静脉麻醉,而异氟烷用于平衡麻醉。方法:共有93例择期行楔形切除术或肺叶切除术的患者纳入一项开放、前瞻性、随机、个体间比较研究。63例患者可获得完整数据集。手术前一晚和当天早晨,患者口服氯氮卓0.5 - 0.7mg/kg进行术前用药。第1组患者以丙泊酚(1.0 - 2.5mg/kg)诱导麻醉,并在50%氧气/空气混合气体中用丙泊酚(4 - 12mg/kg)维持麻醉。第2组患者以美索比妥(1 - 2mg/kg)诱导麻醉,并在50%氧气/空气混合气体中用异氟烷(0.4 - 2.0体积%)维持全身麻醉。两组均使用芬太尼(最大剂量10μg/kg)镇痛,阿曲库铵进行肌肉松弛。在手术前一天(t1)、麻醉诱导前即刻(t2)以及拔管后5分钟、30分钟、60分钟、90分钟、24小时和7天(t3 - t8)进行精神运动测试(简易精神状态检查、反应时间)。在t1、t2以及t5 - t8时间点进行肺功能测定(第1秒用力呼气量,FEV1;用力肺活量,FVC;呼气峰值流速,PEF)。结果:两组患者术前状况(年龄、性别、术前风险评分、精神运动测试及肺功能测定值)及所施行手术(楔形切除术/肺叶切除术、麻醉持续时间)具有可比性。丙泊酚组拔管时间(18±8分钟)略短于异氟烷组(20±6分钟)。此外,丙泊酚组精神运动测试结果也略优于异氟烷组。最明显的差异出现在术后早期,但并非所有差异均具有统计学意义。两组间三项肺功能参数存在统计学上的高度显著差异。根据术后第7天的FEV1值,丙泊酚组拔管后60分钟FEV1下降27.9%,而异氟烷组下降51.7%(P = 0.01)。拔管后90分钟,丙泊酚组相应下降26.6%,异氟烷组下降51.1%(P = 0.003)。此外,拔管后60分钟和90分钟时,丙泊酚组FVC和PEF的下降幅度明显小于异氟烷组。结论:丙泊酚麻醉下肺切除术后肺功能的损害在统计学上显著小于异氟烷麻醉。丙泊酚全静脉麻醉特别适用于此类手术。