Rashiq S, Gallant B, Grace M, Jolly D T
Department of Anaesthesia, University of Alberta, Edmonton.
Can J Anaesth. 1994 Dec;41(12):1166-71. doi: 10.1007/BF03020655.
The purpose of this study was to determine the rate and quality of recovery when general anaesthesia was induced with a mixture of thiopentone and propofol, compared with thiopentone or propofol alone. Sixty ASA class I and II women scheduled for out-patient laparoscopic surgery underwent induction of anaesthesia with either (i) thiopentone, (ii) propofol, or (iii) a mixture of the two, in a randomized, double-blind fashion. Anaesthesia was then maintained using nitrous oxide, isoflurane and fentanyl. A psychometric test was administered before and after surgery, and the time taken to reach a series of recovery milestones was noted. Patients were discharged as soon as they were ambulant and had satisfactory control of pain and nausea with oral agents. They were telephoned at 24-48 hr later, and asked to rate their experience of a list of side effects on an ordinal scale. Patient groups were demographically comparable and underwent surgery of the same duration. Those receiving thiopentone were discharged after a mean time of 3 hr 25 +/- 58 min (SD). The corresponding figures for propofol and the thiopentone/propofol mixture were 2 hr 40 min (+/- 49) and 2 hr 48 min (+/- 68) respectively. The recovery time between thiopentone and the other two regimes was different (P < 0.05). All three groups experienced equally frequent and severe nausea, headache, tiredness and other side effects during the next 24 hr. It is concluded that induction with a mixture of thiopentone and propofol leads to a similar rate and quality of recovery to that of propofol above.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
本研究的目的是确定硫喷妥钠和丙泊酚混合诱导全身麻醉时的恢复速度和质量,并与单独使用硫喷妥钠或丙泊酚进行比较。60例计划接受门诊腹腔镜手术的ASA I级和II级女性患者,以随机、双盲方式分别接受以下麻醉诱导:(i)硫喷妥钠,(ii)丙泊酚,或(iii)两者的混合物。然后使用氧化亚氮、异氟烷和芬太尼维持麻醉。在手术前后进行心理测试,并记录达到一系列恢复里程碑所需的时间。患者一旦能够走动且口服药物能使疼痛和恶心得到满意控制,即可出院。在术后24 - 48小时对患者进行电话随访,要求他们按序数量表对一系列副作用的体验进行评分。各患者组在人口统计学上具有可比性,且手术持续时间相同。接受硫喷妥钠的患者平均在3小时25分 +/- 58分钟(标准差)后出院。丙泊酚组和硫喷妥钠/丙泊酚混合组的相应时间分别为2小时40分钟(+/- 49)和2小时48分钟(+/- 68)。硫喷妥钠组与其他两组的恢复时间不同(P < 0.05)。在接下来的24小时内,三组患者出现恶心、头痛、疲劳及其他副作用的频率和严重程度相同。结论是,硫喷妥钠和丙泊酚混合诱导导致的恢复速度和质量与单独使用丙泊酚相似。(摘要截选至250字)