Lahad A, Malter A D, Berg A O, Deyo R A
Department of Health Services, University of Washington School of Public Health and Community Medicine, Seattle.
JAMA. 1994 Oct 26;272(16):1286-91.
Low back pain affects 60% to 80% of US adults at some time during their lives. This review evaluates the effectiveness of four strategies to prevent low back pain for asymptomatic individuals: back and aerobic exercises, education, mechanical supports (corsets), and risk factor modification.
The MEDLINE database was searched for all relevant articles published in English between 1966 and 1993. Bibliographies of identified articles were searched to ensure that all pertinent articles had been gathered and back pain specialists reviewed our final bibliography for completeness.
A total of 190 articles were identified, and the 64 that contained original data about preventing low back pain were reviewed. Studies were graded according to strength of study design.
There is limited evidence based on randomized trials and epidemiological studies that exercises to strengthen back or abdominal muscles and to improve overall fitness can decrease the incidence and duration of low back pain episodes. There is minimal evidence to support the use of educational strategies to prevent low back pain and insufficient evidence to recommend about the use of mechanical supports. Although there is no evidence supporting risk factor modification for preventing low back pain (smoking cessation and weight loss), there are other reasons to recommend the interventions.
There is limited evidence to recommend exercise to prevent low back pain in asymptomatic individuals, but there is insufficient evidence to recommend other prevention strategies. These conclusions should be viewed cautiously since they are primarily based on studies conducted in the workplace rather than in clinical settings.
在美国,60%至80%的成年人在其一生中的某些时候会受到腰痛困扰。本综述评估了四种针对无症状个体预防腰痛的策略的有效性:背部和有氧运动、教育、机械支撑(束腹带)以及风险因素修正。
检索MEDLINE数据库,查找1966年至1993年间以英文发表的所有相关文章。检索已识别文章的参考文献,以确保收集到所有相关文章,并且腰痛专家审查了我们的最终参考文献以确保完整性。
共识别出190篇文章,其中64篇包含预防腰痛的原始数据,并对其进行了综述。根据研究设计的强度对研究进行分级。
基于随机试验和流行病学研究的证据有限,表明加强背部或腹部肌肉以及提高整体健康水平的运动可以降低腰痛发作的发生率和持续时间。支持使用教育策略预防腰痛的证据极少,推荐使用机械支撑的证据不足。虽然没有证据支持通过修正风险因素(戒烟和减肥)来预防腰痛,但有其他理由推荐这些干预措施。
有有限的证据推荐运动来预防无症状个体的腰痛,但没有足够的证据推荐其他预防策略。这些结论应谨慎看待,因为它们主要基于在工作场所而非临床环境中进行的研究。