Walton M A, Castro F G, Barrington E H
University of Michigan, Alcohol Research Center, Ann Arbor 48108.
Addict Behav. 1994 May-Jun;19(3):319-31. doi: 10.1016/0306-4603(94)90033-7.
This study examined the role of attributions in the lapse and relapse process following substance abuse treatment. According to Marlatt and Gordon's theoretical framework, attributions made after a lapse (e.g., the Abstinence Violation Effect [AVE]) determine whether it progresses to a relapse. Also examined were the attributions of recovering drug users who were tempted but remained abstinent (never lapsed). Ninety-seven participants were recruited from an inpatient treatment center for substance abuse and completed an interview 6 months after leaving treatment. Findings partially confirmed predictions made by the AVE. Predictions made by the AVE were not supported in that lapsers and relapsers were similar regarding their internal/external attributions following a return to drug use; predictions were supported as relapsers made more stable and global attributions as compared to lapsers. Also as predicted, abstainers made more internal, stable, and global attributions regarding their abstinence (as compared to lapsers following their slip). Abstainers' attributions for their success in remaining abstinent tended to be similar to the attributions made by relapsers for their failure to remain abstinent (i.e., for their relapse). Combined, these findings highlight the complexity of the attributional process in early recovery from substance abuse. Clinical and research implications of the findings are discussed in relation to substance abuse relapse prevention.
本研究考察了归因在药物滥用治疗后的失误及复发过程中所起的作用。根据马尔拉特和戈登的理论框架,失误后所做的归因(例如,禁欲违反效应[AVE])决定了它是否会发展为复发。研究还考察了那些受到诱惑但仍保持禁欲(从未失误)的戒毒者的归因情况。从一家药物滥用住院治疗中心招募了97名参与者,他们在出院6个月后完成了一次访谈。研究结果部分证实了AVE所做的预测。AVE所做的预测未得到支持,因为在重新开始使用药物后,失误者和复发者在内部/外部归因方面相似;预测得到支持,因为与失误者相比,复发者做出了更稳定、更全面的归因。同样如预测的那样,禁欲者对其禁欲做出了更内在、更稳定、更全面的归因(与失误后失误者相比)。禁欲者对其成功保持禁欲的归因往往与复发者对其未能保持禁欲(即复发)的归因相似。综合来看,这些发现凸显了药物滥用早期康复中归因过程的复杂性。研究结果的临床和研究意义在与药物滥用复发预防相关的讨论中进行了阐述。