Holmes B, Costas M, Ganner M, On S L, Stevens M
Central Public Health Laboratory, London, England.
J Clin Microbiol. 1994 Aug;32(8):1970-5. doi: 10.1128/jcm.32.8.1970-1975.1994.
The Biolog system (Biolog, Inc., Hayward, Calif.) was evaluated for the identification of 55 gram-negative taxa (789 strains) likely to be encountered commonly in clinical laboratories. The Biolog system performed best with oxidase-positive fermenters and biochemically active nonfermenters and had the most problems with unreactive nonfermenters. It gave significantly better results when the MicroPlates were read manually rather than when they were read by the automated reader. Plates read manually gave the following performances: oxidase-positive fermenters, five taxa, 64 strains, 92% correct, 3% not identified, and 5% incorrect; biochemically active nonfermenters, eight taxa, 122 strains, 88% correct, 6% not identified, and 6% incorrect; members of the family Enterobacteriaceae, 35 taxa, 511 strains, 77% correct, 8% not identified, and 15% incorrect; unreactive nonfermenters, seven taxa, 92 strains, 38% correct, 24% not identified, and 38% incorrect. We found the system easy to use, but while for 39 of 55 of the taxa an identification rate of > 70% was achieved, problems were encountered, particularly with identification of capsulated strains of some Enterobacter and Klebsiella taxa, as well as the least biochemically active Moraxella and Neisseria strains.
对Biolog系统(Biolog公司,加利福尼亚州海沃德市)进行了评估,以鉴定临床实验室中可能常见的55种革兰氏阴性分类单元(789株菌株)。Biolog系统对氧化酶阳性发酵菌和生化活性非发酵菌的鉴定效果最佳,而对无反应性非发酵菌存在最多问题。当手动读取微孔板而非使用自动读数仪读取时,该系统给出的结果明显更好。手动读取的微孔板表现如下:氧化酶阳性发酵菌,5个分类单元,64株菌株,正确识别率92%,未识别率3%,错误识别率5%;生化活性非发酵菌,8个分类单元,122株菌株,正确识别率88%,未识别率6%,错误识别率6%;肠杆菌科成员,35个分类单元,511株菌株,正确识别率77%,未识别率8%,错误识别率15%;无反应性非发酵菌,7个分类单元,92株菌株,正确识别率38%,未识别率24%,错误识别率38%。我们发现该系统易于使用,虽然55个分类单元中的39个实现了>70%的识别率,但仍遇到了问题,特别是在鉴定某些肠杆菌属和克雷伯菌属的荚膜菌株以及生化活性最低的莫拉菌属和奈瑟菌属菌株时。