Pearson D C, Thompson R S
Center for Health Promotion, Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound, Seattle, WA 98101.
Public Health Rep. 1994 Jul-Aug;109(4):571-8.
The goal of this study was to identify areas in which an influenza immunization campaign for seniors, sponsored by a health maintenance organization (HMO), could be improved. This study was conducted at Group Health Cooperative of Puget Sound (GHC), serving approximately 470,000 enrollees in Washington State. A survey was administered to two groups of seniors drawn at random--those who received influenza vaccine and those who did not, during the fall and winter of 1991. Immunization rates were almost 75 percent for "well" seniors and 85 percent for "chronically ill" seniors. Bivariant analysis showed that two activities of the influenza campaign were associated with vaccine compliance: a provider-generated recruitment letter and exposure to an immunization article in the enrollee newsletter. Using a broader framework for predicting vaccine compliance, logistic regression showed that vaccine compliance was associated positively with previous immunizations and belief that "my doctor wants me to get a shot," and negatively with fear of adverse reaction and belief that the vaccine is ineffective. There were few suggestions for improving the immunization program, among both vaccinated and unvaccinated enrollees. Approximately two-thirds of unvaccinated enrollees said there was nothing GHC could do to convince them to be vaccinated. These findings suggest high vaccine compliance and satisfaction with an HMO-sponsored influenza campaign. Strategies and potential to further increase vaccination rates are discussed.
本研究的目的是确定由一家健康维护组织(HMO)发起的针对老年人的流感免疫接种活动中可以改进的方面。这项研究在普吉特海湾集团健康合作社(GHC)开展,该合作社为华盛顿州约47万名参保人提供服务。在1991年秋冬,对随机抽取的两组老年人进行了一项调查——一组是接种了流感疫苗的老年人,另一组是未接种的老年人。“健康”老年人的免疫接种率近75%,“慢性病”老年人的免疫接种率为85%。双变量分析表明,流感接种活动的两项举措与疫苗接种依从性相关:一份由医疗服务提供者发出的招募信函以及参保人时事通讯中一篇关于免疫接种的文章。使用一个更广泛的框架来预测疫苗接种依从性,逻辑回归显示,疫苗接种依从性与之前的免疫接种以及“我的医生希望我接种疫苗”的信念呈正相关,与对不良反应的恐惧以及认为疫苗无效的信念呈负相关。无论是接种了疫苗的参保人还是未接种的参保人,对于改进免疫接种计划的建议都很少。大约三分之二未接种疫苗的参保人表示,GHC没有办法说服他们接种疫苗。这些发现表明疫苗接种依从性较高,且参保人对HMO发起的流感接种活动满意度较高。文中还讨论了进一步提高接种率的策略和潜力。