Frank J W, Henderson M, McMurray L
Can Med Assoc J. 1985 Feb 15;132(4):371-5.
In the autumn of 1982 routine annual influenza vaccination was offered, by reminder letters and follow-up telephone calls, to 273 independent elderly individuals registered at a community health clinic in Hamilton, Ont. The demographic and geographic characteristics and the health beliefs of those who either accepted or did not accept the vaccine were compared. Among those who received reminder letters there were no significant differences in the rates of vaccine acceptance according to age, sex, household composition or ease of access to the clinic. The patients who reported having previously experienced side effects from the vaccine and perceived a lack of efficacy of the vaccine were more likely not to accept it this time. Both a lack of effort by health care providers (to promote vaccination) and patient behaviour appeared to contribute to pre-existing low levels of influenza vaccination coverage. Although physicians' efforts to inform patients about the vaccination clinics resulted in a tripling of the overall rate of acceptance of the vaccine, there remained a "hard core" of almost half the patients who were unwilling to receive the vaccine, apparently because they perceived its risks to outweigh its benefits.
1982年秋,通过提醒信函和后续电话联系,向安大略省汉密尔顿市一家社区健康诊所登记的273名独立老年人提供了常规年度流感疫苗接种服务。对接受或未接受疫苗接种者的人口统计学和地理特征以及健康观念进行了比较。在收到提醒信函的人群中,根据年龄、性别、家庭构成或前往诊所的便利程度,疫苗接种率没有显著差异。报告曾有过疫苗副作用经历且认为疫苗缺乏效力的患者此次更有可能不接受接种。医疗保健提供者(推广疫苗接种)的努力不足和患者行为似乎都导致了流感疫苗接种覆盖率原本就较低的情况。尽管医生告知患者有关疫苗接种诊所的努力使疫苗总体接种率提高了两倍,但仍有近一半的患者是“顽固分子”,他们不愿意接种疫苗,显然是因为他们认为疫苗的风险大于益处。