Glenmark B, Hedberg G, Kaijser L, Jansson E
Department of Clinical Physiology, Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden.
Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol. 1994;68(1):9-19. doi: 10.1007/BF00599235.
The aim of the present study was to reinvestigate muscle strength and the relationship to muscle fibre and the level of physical activity in adult men and women previously studied during adolescence. A group of 55 men and 26 women were tested for maximal strength (handgrip, Sargent jump and two-hand lift) and completed a questionnaire concerning physical activity during their leisure time (activity index) at the ages of 16 and 27 years. Biopsy specimens were taken from the vastus lateralis and analysed for fibre type (percentage of I, IIA, IIB) and fibre area (area I, area IIA, area IIB). The sex differences in strength increased from age 16 to 17 years. Body dimension, sex, percentage of type II, mean fibre area and the activity index contributed to explaining 50-75% of the strength at both ages. Different changes in relationship between fibre type composition and strength in women and men was seen with increasing age. In the women, the relationship between strength and the percentage of type II fibres changed with age (from 16 to 27 years of age) from a positive correlation (only Sargent jump) to negative correlations for all the strength tests, i.e. the more type I fibres the stronger the subject. A positive correlation between strength and the level of physical activity during leisure time was revealed in the women at both ages. The positive correlation between strength and type II fibres in the 16-year-old men had disappeared at age 27. No systematic relationships between strength and the level of physical activity were seen in the men at either 16 or 27 years of age. It is suggested that women may be more dependent on physical activity than adult men to develop strength and the percentage of type I fibres reflects the degree of physical activity among adult women but not among adolescent women.
本研究的目的是重新调查曾在青春期接受过研究的成年男性和女性的肌肉力量,以及肌肉力量与肌纤维和身体活动水平之间的关系。对一组55名男性和26名女性进行了最大力量测试(握力、萨金特纵跳和双手推举),并让他们填写了一份关于16岁和27岁时休闲时间身体活动情况的问卷(活动指数)。从股外侧肌采集活检标本,分析纤维类型(I型、IIA型、IIB型的百分比)和纤维面积(I型面积、IIA型面积、IIB型面积)。力量的性别差异在16岁至17岁之间增大。身体尺寸、性别、II型纤维百分比、平均纤维面积和活动指数有助于解释两个年龄段50%至75%的力量差异。随着年龄增长,男性和女性的纤维类型组成与力量之间的关系出现了不同变化。在女性中,力量与II型纤维百分比之间的关系随年龄(从16岁到27岁)变化,从正相关(仅萨金特纵跳)变为所有力量测试的负相关,即I型纤维越多,受试者越强。在两个年龄段的女性中,均发现力量与休闲时间身体活动水平呈正相关。16岁男性中力量与II型纤维之间的正相关在27岁时消失。在16岁和27岁的男性中,均未发现力量与身体活动水平之间存在系统关系。研究表明,女性在发展力量方面可能比成年男性更依赖身体活动,I型纤维百分比反映了成年女性而非青春期女性的身体活动程度。