Speiser B L, Spratling L
Department of Radiation Oncology, St. Joseph's Hospital, Phoenix, AZ 85013.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1993 Mar 15;25(4):579-87. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(93)90002-d.
The study was designed to, (a) standardize endobronchial brachytherapy and, (b) to evaluate the relief of obstructive signs and symptoms.
Patients with endobronchial carcinoma were treated on a protocol (n = 342) with remote afterloading brachytherapy. Group 1 patients were treated with medium dose rate and received 1000 cGy at 5 mm depth for three fractions (n = 47). Group 2 were treated with high dose rate, 1000 cGy to a 10 mm depth for three fractions (n = 144) and Group 3 received 750 cGy delivered to a 10 mm depth for three fractions (n = 151). Each group was divided into curative, palliative, and recurrent categories. Neodymium yttrium aluminum garnet photoresection was used in 24% of patients prior to brachytherapy.
Evaluation consisted of symptom index scoring with weighted responses of hemoptysis 99%, obstructive pneumonia 99%, cough 85%, and dyspnea 86%. Obstruction improvement was 80% overall, curative 87%, palliative 84%, and recurrent 70% of mean pretreatment scores. Survival 10% alive, 88% expired, and 2% lost to follow-up. Cause of death was intrathoracic carcinoma 41%, metastatic carcinoma 38%, intercurrent disease 9%, and unknown cause 13%. Survival from diagnosis and first treatment was, respectively, for curative 10.8 and 9.5 months, palliative 14 and 5.6 months, and recurrent 25.6 and 6.2 months. Significant complications were fatal hemoptysis 7%, and radiation bronchitis and stenosis 11%.
Endoluminal brachytherapy provides excellent palliation of the endobronchial portion of neoplastic disease.
本研究旨在,(a)规范支气管内近距离放射治疗,以及(b)评估阻塞性体征和症状的缓解情况。
支气管内癌患者按照一项方案(n = 342)接受遥控后装近距离放射治疗。第1组患者采用中剂量率治疗,在5毫米深度接受1000厘戈瑞,分三次照射(n = 47)。第2组采用高剂量率治疗,在10毫米深度接受1000厘戈瑞,分三次照射(n = 144),第3组在10毫米深度接受750厘戈瑞,分三次照射(n = 151)。每组又分为根治性、姑息性和复发性类别。24%的患者在近距离放射治疗前接受了钕钇铝石榴石激光切除。
评估包括症状指数评分,咯血加权反应为99%,阻塞性肺炎为99%,咳嗽为85%,呼吸困难为86%。总体阻塞改善率为80%,根治性为87%,姑息性为84%,复发性为平均治疗前评分的70%。10%存活,88%死亡,2%失访。死亡原因是胸内癌41%,转移性癌38%,并发疾病9%,原因不明13%。从诊断和首次治疗开始的生存期,根治性分别为10.8个月和9.5个月,姑息性为14个月和5.6个月,复发性为25.6个月和6.2个月。显著并发症为致命咯血7%,放射性支气管炎和狭窄11%。
腔内近距离放射治疗对肿瘤性疾病的支气管内部分提供了良好的姑息治疗效果。