Marks B L, Ward A, Morris D H, Castellani J, Rippe J M
Exercise Physiology and Nutrition Laboratory, University of Massachusetts Medical Center, Worcester, USA.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 1995 Sep;27(9):1243-51.
Weight-loss programs usually result in fat-free mass (FFM) loss along with body-fat (BF) loss. This study examined which combination of diet + exercise would maintain FFM. Forty-four overweight, inactive women completed 20 wk of a randomized intervention: control (C, N = 6), diet only (D, N = 10), diet + cycling (DC, N = 8), diet + resistance training (DR, N = 11), or diet + resistance training + cycling (DRC, N = 9) group. FFM and %BF were determined from hydrostatic weighting. Exercise sessions were attended 3 d.wk-1, with a mean duration of 30 min per session. Caloric intake was reduced 628 kcal.d-1 (+/- 59). Chi squares and ANOVA showed no baseline differences between groups for socioeconomic status, age, body composition, aerobic capacity, or strength. One-way ANOVA of change with Student-Newman Keul multiple range post-hoc tests (P < 0.05) were used to analyze pre to post differences for %BF, body mass (BM), FFM, VO2max, and strength. D, DC, DR, and DRC lost significant BM (-3.7 to -5.4 kg) in comparison with C (+ 1.5 kg). All groups maintained FFM but only DRC significantly lowered %BF (-4.7%) in comparison with C. DRC and DC significantly increased VO2max. Strength 1RM (triceps extension, arm curl, leg extension, chest press) increased significantly for both DR and DRC. Results suggest that moderate levels of caloric restriction, aerobic cycle exercise, and/or resistance training are equally effective in maintaining FFM while encouraging body mass loss.
减肥计划通常会导致无脂肪体重(FFM)和体脂(BF)同时减少。本研究考察了哪种饮食与运动的组合能维持无脂肪体重。44名超重、缺乏运动的女性完成了为期20周的随机干预:对照组(C,N = 6)、仅节食组(D,N = 10)、节食 + 骑自行车组(DC,N = 8)、节食 + 抗阻训练组(DR,N = 11)或节食 + 抗阻训练 + 骑自行车组(DRC,N = 9)。通过水下称重法测定无脂肪体重和体脂百分比。运动课程每周进行3天,每次平均时长30分钟。热量摄入减少628千卡/天(±59)。卡方检验和方差分析表明,各组在社会经济地位、年龄、身体成分、有氧能力或力量方面基线无差异。采用单因素方差分析及Student - Newman Keul多重范围事后检验(P < 0.05)分析体脂百分比、体重(BM)、无脂肪体重、最大摄氧量(VO2max)和力量在干预前后的差异。与C组(体重增加1.5千克)相比,D组、DC组、DR组和DRC组体重显著下降(-3.7至-5.4千克)。所有组均维持了无脂肪体重,但与C组相比,只有DRC组显著降低了体脂百分比(-4.7%)。DRC组和DC组显著提高了最大摄氧量。DR组和DRC组的力量1RM(肱三头肌伸展、弯臂举、腿部伸展、卧推)均显著增加。结果表明,适度的热量限制、有氧自行车运动和/或抗阻训练在维持无脂肪体重同时促进体重减轻方面同样有效。