Smit J W, Van Erpecum K J, Portincasa P, Renooij W, Erkelens D W, Van Berge-Henegouwen G P
Department of Gastroenterology, University Hospital, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Gut. 1995 Nov;37(5):654-9. doi: 10.1136/gut.37.5.654.
Although the effects of 3-hydroxy, 3-methylglutaryl coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase inhibitors and bile acid sequestrants on bile lipid composition have been studied separately, no data are available on combination therapy of these drugs. Moreover, the effects of prolonged (four weeks) administration of these drugs on gall bladder motility, an important determinant of cholesterol gall stone formation, have not been studied so far. A prospective study was therefore performed with eight patients who had hypercholesterolaemia (age 53 (5) (SEM), body mass index 27.4 (1.1) kg m-2, low density lipoprotein cholesterol 5.9 (0.3) mmol/l). They received treatment during three periods of four weeks with simvastatin 20 mg/day, cholestyramine 4 g twice daily, and a combination of both in random order, each treatment period separated by a two week wash out period. Before treatment and after each treatment period, postprandial gall bladder motility was studied with ultrasound, followed by duodenal bile sampling. Serum cholesterol decreased in all subjects in any treatment period illustrating good compliance. Molar percentages in duodenal bile of cholesterol, phospholipids, and bile salts were unchanged during simvastatin and cholestyramine treatment. During combined therapy percentage bile salts was lower (72.5 (2.9)% v 77.8 (1.7)% at baseline, p < 0.05) whereas phospholipids were higher (21.2 (2.4)% v 16.4 (1.3)% at baseline, p < 0.05). As a result cholesterol saturation index (CSI) did not change in any treatment period. No cholesterol crystals were detected in any bile sample, taken at baseline and after each treatment period. Bile salt hydrophobicity index during cholestyramine (0.19 (0.02)) and combined treatment (0.22 (0.01)) decreased strongly compared with baseline (0.34 (0.01), p < 0.001, p < 0.01, respectively), resulting from increased proportions of glycocholate (59.4 (3.9)% (cholestyramine), 55.6 (2.4)% (combination), and 28.2 (2.2) (baseline), p < 0.001)) and decreased proportions of deoxycholic acid and chenodeoxycholic acid. Fasting gall bladder volume was increased during simvastatin (28.7 (2.8) ml) v baseline (23.2 (2.3) ml, p < 0.01) whereas, residual volume did not differ (5.7 (0.9) ml (simvastatin) v 5.9 (0.7) (baseline). During cholestyramine and combined treatment, no significant differences in gall bladder motility were seen. In conclusion, this study suggests that HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors alone and combined with cholestyramine do not affect major determinants of cholesterol gall stone formation, for example, CSI and gall bladder emptying. In addition cholestyramine alone and combined with simvastatin leads to a strong decrease of bile salt hydrophobicity, which may be beneficial in the prevention of nucleation of cholesterol crystals.
尽管已经分别研究了3-羟基-3-甲基戊二酰辅酶A(HMG-CoA)还原酶抑制剂和胆汁酸螯合剂对胆汁脂质成分的影响,但关于这些药物联合治疗的数据尚无可用。此外,这些药物长期(四周)给药对胆囊运动(胆固醇胆结石形成的一个重要决定因素)的影响迄今为止尚未得到研究。因此,对八名患有高胆固醇血症的患者进行了一项前瞻性研究(年龄53(5)(标准误),体重指数27.4(1.1)kg/m²,低密度脂蛋白胆固醇5.9(0.3)mmol/L)。他们在三个为期四周的阶段接受治疗,分别为每天20毫克辛伐他汀、每天两次4克考来烯胺以及两者的联合用药,用药顺序随机,每个治疗阶段之间有两周的洗脱期。在治疗前以及每个治疗阶段后,用超声研究餐后胆囊运动,随后进行十二指肠胆汁采样。在任何治疗阶段,所有受试者的血清胆固醇均下降,表明依从性良好。在辛伐他汀和考来烯胺治疗期间,十二指肠胆汁中胆固醇、磷脂和胆汁盐的摩尔百分比未发生变化。在联合治疗期间,胆汁盐百分比更低(基线时为77.8(1.7)%,联合治疗时为72.5(2.9)%,p<0.05),而磷脂更高(基线时为16.4(1.3)%,联合治疗时为21.2(2.4)%,p<0.05)。结果,在任何治疗阶段胆固醇饱和指数(CSI)均未改变。在基线时以及每个治疗阶段后采集的任何胆汁样本中均未检测到胆固醇结晶。考来烯胺治疗期间(0.19(0.02))和联合治疗期间(0.22(0.01))的胆汁盐疏水性指数与基线相比(0.34(0.01))大幅下降(分别为p<0.001,p<0.01),这是由于甘胆酸盐比例增加(考来烯胺治疗时为59.4(3.9)%,联合治疗时为55.6(2.4)%,基线时为28.2(2.2)%,p<0.001)以及脱氧胆酸和鹅去氧胆酸比例下降所致。辛伐他汀治疗期间空腹胆囊体积增加(28.7(2.8)ml),而基线时为(23.2(2.3)ml,p<0.01),而残余体积无差异(辛伐他汀治疗时为5.7(0.9)ml,基线时为5.9(0.7)ml)。在考来烯胺和联合治疗期间,未观察到胆囊运动有显著差异。总之,本研究表明,单独使用HMG-CoA还原酶抑制剂以及与考来烯胺联合使用均不会影响胆固醇胆结石形成的主要决定因素,例如CSI和胆囊排空。此外,单独使用考来烯胺以及与辛伐他汀联合使用会导致胆汁盐疏水性大幅降低,这可能有利于预防胆固醇结晶的成核。