Bowman R J, Lwitt D G
Biochim Biophys Acta. 1977 Apr 1;466(1):68-83. doi: 10.1016/0005-2736(77)90209-7.
The kinetic equations describing transport through a pore that has a binding site and that undergoes a conformational change are identical to those of a carrier model. Therefore, in order to distinguish between the two models it is necessary to test specific predictions based on detailed mechanistic models. A pore model is described in which the substrate (glucose) is able to reach the single binding site only from the outside when the pore is in conformation I and only from the inside when it is conformation II. On the basis of this model it is predicted that solutes which do not have any specific affinity for the binding site should still have a finite permeability via the glucose transport system if they are the same size or smaller than glucose. This permeability should be proportional to the volume of distribution of the solute in the pore and should therefore decrease with increasing molecular size. A geometric pore volume can be estimated from this size dependence. In order to test these predictions, the glucose-dependent permeability of a series of 4-carbon (erythritol), 5-carbon (D-arabitol, L-arabitol and xylitol) and 6-carbon (D-mannitol, D-sorbitol and myo-inositol) polyols was measured. The permeability of all the polyols is decreased by the presence of glucose and the KI of this "inhibitable" component is similar to that D-sorbose, suggesting that this component is associated with the glucose transport system. Since these observations could be explained entirely in terms of a specific affinity for a carrier binding site, they do not exclude a carrier mechanism. However, as predicted for the pore model, this "inhibitable" permeability decreased with increasing molecular size and the calculated geometric pore volume was of a size that would be expected for a cell membrane pore.
描述通过具有结合位点且会发生构象变化的孔道进行转运的动力学方程与载体模型的动力学方程相同。因此,为了区分这两种模型,有必要基于详细的机理模型来测试特定的预测。文中描述了一种孔道模型,其中底物(葡萄糖)只有在孔道处于构象I时才能从外部到达单一结合位点,而在构象II时只能从内部到达。基于该模型预测,如果溶质与葡萄糖大小相同或小于葡萄糖,那么对结合位点没有任何特异性亲和力的溶质通过葡萄糖转运系统仍应具有一定的通透性。这种通透性应与溶质在孔道中的分布体积成正比,因此应随分子大小的增加而降低。可以根据这种大小依赖性估算出几何孔体积。为了验证这些预测,测量了一系列四碳(赤藓糖醇)、五碳(D-阿拉伯糖醇、L-阿拉伯糖醇和木糖醇)和六碳(D-甘露醇、D-山梨醇和肌醇)多元醇的葡萄糖依赖性通透性。所有多元醇的通透性都因葡萄糖的存在而降低,且这种“可抑制”成分的KI与D-山梨糖的KI相似,这表明该成分与葡萄糖转运系统有关。由于这些观察结果完全可以用对载体结合位点的特异性亲和力来解释,所以它们并不排除载体机制。然而,正如孔道模型所预测的那样,这种“可抑制”的通透性随分子大小的增加而降低,并且计算出的几何孔体积大小与细胞膜孔预期的大小相符。