Petersen C S, Agner T, Ottevanger V, Larsen J, Ravnborg L
Department of Dermato-venereology, Gentofte Hospital, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Genitourin Med. 1995 Dec;71(6):391-2. doi: 10.1136/sti.71.6.391.
To evaluate the efficacy-safety ratio of a new topical podophyllotoxin cream 0.5% compared with podophyllotoxin solution 0.5% (Condyline) in male patients with genital warts.
In an observer-blinded controlled study a total of 136 and 133 wart lesions were treated with podophyllotoxin cream 0.5% and podophyllotoxin solution 0.5%, respectively. The preparations were applied twice daily for 3 days, repeated with 4 days intervals for a minimum of two and a maximum of four treatment cycles.
At the conclusion of the study (8 weeks after completion of therapy) a significant reduction in mean wart area was observed in both the cream group (87.7, SD 8.4 to 20.6, SD 2.7) and in the solution group (92.3, SD 7.5 to 21.5, SD 2.8) (p < 0.01). At the same time all treated warts had completely cleared in 63% of patients in both study groups. Mild to moderate side effects occurred to the same extent in both podophyllotoxin cream and podophyllotoxin solution recipients.
We conclude that podophyllotoxin 0.5% administered in a cream formulation does not give additional clinical benefits when compared with podophyllotoxin solution 0.5% in male patients with external genital warts.
评估0.5%新型鬼臼毒素乳膏与0.5%鬼臼毒素溶液(疣敌)相比,治疗男性尖锐湿疣患者的疗效-安全性比。
在一项观察者盲法对照研究中,分别用0.5%鬼臼毒素乳膏和0.5%鬼臼毒素溶液治疗了总共136个和133个疣体。制剂每日涂抹两次,共3天,间隔4天重复,最少进行2个最多进行4个治疗周期。
在研究结束时(治疗完成后8周),乳膏组(平均疣体面积从87.7,标准差8.4降至20.6,标准差2.7)和溶液组(从92.3,标准差7.5降至21.5,标准差2.8)的平均疣体面积均显著减小(p < 0.01)。同时,两个研究组中均有63%的患者所有治疗的疣体完全清除。接受鬼臼毒素乳膏和鬼臼毒素溶液治疗的患者出现轻至中度副作用的程度相同。
我们得出结论,对于男性外生殖器疣患者,0.5%鬼臼毒素乳膏与0.5%鬼臼毒素溶液相比,并未带来额外的临床益处。