Meyers A R, Perrine M W
Boston University School of Medicine, Massachusetts 02118, USA.
J Stud Alcohol. 1996 Mar;57(2):187-92. doi: 10.15288/jsa.1996.57.187.
This study compares police officers' reported alcohol use with similar reports from age- and gender-matched samples from the general driving population (GDP) and drivers recruited at high-risk hours who are most likely to drink and drive (roadside drivers).
Data were derived from interviews with 239 police officers who spent at least 5% of their time on alcohol or traffic enforcement; 243 subjects from the GDP, selected by random-digit dialing; and 249 drivers recruited at roadside on Friday and Saturday nights between 10:00 PM and 3:00 AM.
Officers report drinking less frequently and in smaller quantities than either of the driver samples. Differences between police and general drivers are modest: e.g., usual frequency of drinking (1 to < 3 vs 3 or 4 times/month; p < or = .001) and number of days/average month with > or = 2 drinks/day (mean = 2.5 [+/- 3.4] vs 4.9 [+/- 6.5]; p < or = .001). There are greater differences between police officers and roadside drivers: e.g., 14.2% and 2.4%, respectively, abstain (vs 15.6% of general drivers; police vs general drivers; NS; police and general drivers vs roadside drivers, p < or = .001).
The data suggest that officers' drinking differs significantly from that of drivers most likely to be driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI). If this is so, police training programs pertaining to DUI and other alcohol-related offenses should pay explicit attention to the effects of alcohol and not assume that all officers have experienced them.
本研究比较了警官报告的饮酒情况与来自一般驾驶人群(GDP)中年龄和性别匹配样本以及在高风险时段招募的最有可能酒后驾车的司机(路边司机)的类似报告。
数据来自对239名警官的访谈,这些警官至少将5%的时间用于酒精或交通执法;通过随机数字拨号从GDP中选取243名受试者;以及在周五和周六晚上10点至凌晨3点在路边招募的249名司机。
警官报告的饮酒频率和饮酒量均低于任何一个司机样本。警察与一般司机之间的差异不大:例如,通常饮酒频率(1至<3次/月与3或4次/月;p≤.001)以及每月平均饮酒≥2杯的天数(平均=2.5[±3.4]与4.9[±6.5];p≤.001)。警察与路边司机之间的差异更大:例如,分别有14.2%和2.4%的人戒酒(而一般司机为15.6%;警察与一般司机相比,无显著差异;警察和一般司机与路边司机相比,p≤.001)。
数据表明,警官的饮酒情况与最有可能在酒精影响下驾驶(DUI)的司机有显著差异。如果是这样,与DUI和其他与酒精相关犯罪有关的警察培训项目应明确关注酒精的影响,而不应假定所有警官都有过此类经历。