Kahana M J
Center for Complex Systems, Brandeis University, Waltham, MA 02254-9110, USA.
Mem Cognit. 1996 Jan;24(1):103-9. doi: 10.3758/bf03197276.
I present a new method for analyzing associative processes in free recall. While previous research has emphasized the prominence of semantic organization, the present method illustrates the importance of association by contiguity. This is done by examining conditional response probabilities in the output sequence. For a given item recalled, I examine the probability and latency that it follows an item from a nearby or distant input position. These conditional probabilities and latencies, plotted as a function of the lag between studied items, reveal several regularities about output order in free recall. First, subjects tend to recall items more often and more rapidly from adjacent input positions than from remote input positions. Second, subjects are about twice as likely to recall adjacent pairs in the forward than in the backward direction and are significantly faster in doing so. These effects are observed at all positions in the output sequence. The asymmetry effect is theoretically significant because, in cued recall, nearly symmetric retrieval is found at all serial positions (Kahana, 1995; Murdock, 1962). An attempt is made to fit the search of associative memory model (Raaijmakers & Shiffrin, 1980, 1981) with and without symmetric interitem associations to these data. Other models of free recall are also discussed.
我提出了一种分析自由回忆中联想过程的新方法。虽然先前的研究强调语义组织的突出性,但本方法通过邻接性说明了联想的重要性。这是通过检查输出序列中的条件反应概率来实现的。对于回忆出的给定项目,我研究它跟随附近或遥远输入位置的项目之后出现的概率和潜伏期。这些条件概率和潜伏期作为所研究项目之间滞后时间的函数绘制出来,揭示了自由回忆中输出顺序的几个规律。首先,与从遥远输入位置相比,受试者从相邻输入位置回忆项目的频率更高、速度更快。其次,受试者正向回忆相邻对的可能性大约是反向回忆的两倍,并且这样做的速度明显更快。在输出序列的所有位置都观察到了这些效应。不对称效应在理论上具有重要意义,因为在线索回忆中,在所有序列位置都发现了几乎对称的检索(卡哈纳,1995;默多克,1962)。尝试将有无对称项目间联想的联想记忆搜索模型(拉伊马克斯和希夫林,1980年、1981年)与这些数据进行拟合。还讨论了其他自由回忆模型。