Lippel K, Ahmed S, Albers J J, Bachorik P, Cooper G, Helms R, Williams J
Clin Chem. 1977 Sep;23(9):1744-52.
Twelve Lipid-Research Clinic laboratories performed automated cholesterol analyses on four control-serum pools of known cholesterol concentration, using the Liebermann-Burchard reaction. The analyses were done during a two-year period, with the same standards, methodology, and quality-control procedures. Estimates of analytical bias, variability, and short- and long-term trends for each instrument and for the entire group of LRC instruments are presented. High accuracy, precision, and interlaboratory comparability were achieved through the rigorous standardization and control of the entire analytical procedure. The significance of these results for long-term collaborative studies is discussed. Individual laboratory biases averaged from 0.5 to 2.0% below Abell-Kendall reference values. Between-run variability was about equal to within-run variability and inter-laboratory variation was substantially less than intra-laboratory variation. The total standard deviation for all instruments was about 0.04 g/liter. Only 8-15% of this variation was due to differences between instruments. The between-instrument standard deviation ranged from 0.011 to 0.015 g/liter; the between-run, within-instrument standard deviation ranged from 0.023 to 0.030 g/liter; and within-run standard deviation ranged from 0.023 to 0.028 g/liter. The significance of the achieved results for long-term collaborative studies is discussed.
12个脂质研究诊所实验室使用利伯曼-布赫ard反应对4个已知胆固醇浓度的对照血清样本进行了自动胆固醇分析。这些分析在两年期间内进行,采用相同的标准、方法和质量控制程序。给出了每台仪器以及脂质研究诊所仪器整个组的分析偏差、变异性以及短期和长期趋势的估计值。通过对整个分析程序进行严格的标准化和控制,实现了高精度、高精确度和实验室间的可比性。讨论了这些结果对于长期合作研究的意义。各个实验室的偏差平均比阿贝尔-肯德尔参考值低0.5%至2.0%。批间变异性与批内变异性大致相当,而实验室间变异性明显小于实验室内变异性。所有仪器的总标准差约为0.04克/升。这种变异性中只有8%至15%是由于仪器之间的差异所致。仪器间标准差范围为0.011至0.015克/升;批间、仪器内标准差范围为0.023至0.030克/升;批内标准差范围为0.023至0.028克/升。讨论了所取得的结果对于长期合作研究的意义。