Loeken K, Steine S, Sandvik L, Laerum E
Department Group for Community Medicine, University of Oslo, Norway.
Med Care. 1997 Jul;35(7):731-41. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199707000-00006.
The benefit of mammography depends on repeated use. Therefore, surveying the mammographic quality as judged by the users addresses an important topic. The authors assess the practicality, validity, reliability, and discriminatory power of a new, brief, multidimensional questionnaire for measuring patient satisfaction with mammography. Items measuring discomfort and attitudes toward repeat adherence were included.
A self-administered questionnaire was given to women from six radiology departments in Norway. Four hundred eighty-eight out of 550 women referred for screening or diagnostic mammography were included. Seventy-seven patients also completed the test/retest study, and 44 women additionally completed an Australian questionnaire. Scores for patient satisfaction on the structure, process, discomfort, and general satisfaction scales of the questionnaire were used as the main outcome measures.
Response rate was 89%, and rate of completion was more than 95%. Strict psychometric criteria for construct validity and reliability were satisfied. Because lower levels of satisfaction were detectable with the new questionnaire but not with the Australian questionnaire and because an acceptable degree of variability in response was detected, support for discriminatory power was found.
The discomfort dimension contributed substantially to validity and discriminatory power. Patient behavior with time may be monitored with the new questionnaire, thus representing a valuable tool for scientific and practical purposes.
乳腺钼靶检查的益处取决于重复使用。因此,调查使用者所评判的乳腺钼靶检查质量是一个重要课题。作者评估一种新的、简短的、多维度问卷在测量患者对乳腺钼靶检查满意度方面的实用性、有效性、可靠性和区分能力。问卷中包含了测量不适以及对重复检查依从性态度的项目。
向挪威六个放射科的女性发放一份自填式问卷。在550名被转诊进行筛查或诊断性乳腺钼靶检查的女性中,有488名被纳入研究。77名患者还完成了重测研究,44名女性额外完成了一份澳大利亚问卷。问卷中关于结构、过程、不适和总体满意度量表的患者满意度得分被用作主要结局指标。
回复率为89%,完成率超过95%。满足了关于结构效度和信度的严格心理测量标准。由于新问卷能够检测到较低水平的满意度,而澳大利亚问卷则不能,并且由于检测到了可接受程度的反应变异性,因此发现了对区分能力的支持。
不适维度对效度和区分能力有很大贡献。新问卷可用于监测患者随时间的行为,因此是科学和实际应用中的一种有价值的工具。