Cook T M, Britton D C, Craft T M, Jones C B, Horrocks M
Royal United Hospital, Bath.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 1997 Sep;79(5):361-7.
An audit was carried out of 102 patients aged over 75 years undergoing urgent or emergency surgery in a district general hospital. The risk of death in hospital after general surgery (13 deaths in 49 patients) was greater than after orthopaedic surgery (two deaths in 53 patients) (P < 0.05). In particular, laparotomy carried a high in-hospital mortality: 12 of 25 patients undergoing laparotomy died. Risk of death after general surgery increased with increasing preoperative ASA class, increasing medical risk factors and duration of operation. Orthopaedic cases were fitter than the general surgical cases as determined by ASA class and the number of medical risk factors. NCEPOD has recommended increased involvement of senior medical staff in operations, reduced night-time operating and avoidance of futile surgery. A high proportion of cases were operated on and anaesthetised by higher specialist trainees and consultants. Death rate was not affected by the seniority of doctors involved, nor by the time of day the operation took place. General surgical deaths were predictable postoperatively in most cases, but preoperative prediction of outcome was not specific enough to alter management.
对一家区综合医院102名75岁以上接受急诊或紧急手术的患者进行了一项审计。普通外科手术后的院内死亡风险(49例患者中有13例死亡)高于骨科手术后的死亡风险(53例患者中有2例死亡)(P<0.05)。特别是,剖腹手术的院内死亡率很高:25例接受剖腹手术的患者中有12例死亡。普通外科手术后的死亡风险随着术前ASA分级的增加、医疗风险因素的增加和手术时间的延长而增加。根据ASA分级和医疗风险因素的数量判断,骨科病例比普通外科病例身体状况更好。国家医疗保健质量改进与保护委员会(NCEPOD)建议增加高级医务人员参与手术,减少夜间手术,并避免进行无意义的手术。很大一部分病例由高级专科培训医生和顾问进行手术和麻醉。死亡率不受参与手术的医生资历影响,也不受手术时间的影响。大多数情况下,普通外科手术死亡在术后是可预测的,但术前对结果的预测不够准确,不足以改变治疗方案。