Takei N, Persaud R, Woodruff P, Brockington I, Murray R M
Department of Psychological Medicine, Institute of Psychiatry, Denmark Hill, London.
Br J Psychiatry. 1998 Feb;172:147-53. doi: 10.1192/bjp.172.2.147.
There have been few prospective studies of the long-term outcome of psychosis in people of Afro-Caribbean origin in the UK.
We followed-up a population-based, consecutive series of 34 Afro-Caribbean and 54 White people with psychosis who had been extensively investigated during their first admission in 1973/74. Diagnoses were made by direct interview using the Present State Examination at both first admission and follow-up.
Ninety-seven percent of the original sample were traced. A slightly greater proportion of the Afro-Caribbean people were assigned to the S+ Catego class (schizophrenia), both on first assessment and at follow-up. No difference was found between the two groups in the consistency of diagnosis over the 18 years or in the proportion of patients considered psychotic but Afro-Caribbean people tended to have fewer negative symptoms at follow-up. There were striking differences between the two groups in their experience of psychiatric care; Afro-Caribbean people were more likely to have been readmitted, to have experienced longer hospitalisations, and to have undergone more involuntary admissions than their White counterparts.
Afro-Caribbean people who met clinical and research criteria for schizophrenia had a less satisfactory experience of, and response to, psychiatric care over 18 years than their White counterparts.
在英国,针对非洲加勒比裔精神病患者长期预后的前瞻性研究较少。
我们对1973/74年首次入院时接受过广泛调查的34名非洲加勒比裔和54名白人精神病患者进行了基于人群的连续随访。首次入院和随访时均通过使用现况检查进行直接访谈来做出诊断。
追踪到了原样本的97%。在首次评估和随访时,非洲加勒比裔人群中被归类为S+类别(精神分裂症)的比例略高。两组在18年的诊断一致性或被视为患有精神病的患者比例方面没有差异,但非洲加勒比裔人群在随访时的阴性症状往往较少。两组在精神科护理经历方面存在显著差异;与白人相比,非洲加勒比裔人群更有可能再次入院、住院时间更长且非自愿入院的次数更多。
符合精神分裂症临床和研究标准的非洲加勒比裔人群在18年期间对精神科护理的体验和反应不如白人患者满意。