Trnka L, Dankova D, Zitova J, Cimprichova L, Migliori G B, Clancy L, Zellweger J P
Tuberculosis Surveillance Unit, Clinic of Pneumology and Chest Surgery, University Hospital, Prague Bulovka, Czech Republic.
Bull World Health Organ. 1998;76(1):85-91.
A retrospective survey, based on a standardized questionnaire sent to qualified public health experts in tuberculosis in 50 European countries, was carried out to evaluate the following: concordance between national vaccination programmes and WHO recommendations on BCG vaccination for prevention of tuberculosis; relation between BCG vaccination and revaccination policy and the tuberculosis epidemiological situation; and differences in BCG vaccination policy between Western and Central-Eastern European countries. The results obtained (from 41 (82%) of the 50 countries) revealed that BCG vaccination programmes met WHO recommendations in 44% of European countries. Mass primary vaccination and general revaccination were extremely common in countries where the prevalence of tuberculosis was high. A highly significant difference was found between Western and Central-Eastern European countries in terms of their adhesion to WHO recommendations. Within Central-Eastern Europe no difference was found between countries that had or had not been part of the former Soviet Union. The implementation of WHO recommendations into national tuberculosis programmes must be intensified, based on the available body of evidence. Preventive methods whose cost-effectiveness has not been properly established should be discouraged.
一项回顾性调查展开,该调查基于向50个欧洲国家合格的结核病公共卫生专家发送的标准化问卷,旨在评估以下内容:国家疫苗接种计划与世界卫生组织关于预防结核病的卡介苗接种建议之间的一致性;卡介苗接种和再接种政策与结核病流行状况之间的关系;以及西欧国家和中东欧国家在卡介苗接种政策上的差异。所获得的结果(来自50个国家中的41个国家(82%))显示,在44%的欧洲国家,卡介苗接种计划符合世界卫生组织的建议。在结核病患病率高的国家,大规模初次接种和普遍再接种极为常见。在遵守世界卫生组织建议方面,西欧国家和中东欧国家之间存在非常显著的差异。在中东欧地区,曾是或未曾是前苏联一部分的国家之间未发现差异。必须根据现有证据,加强将世界卫生组织建议纳入国家结核病计划的工作。不应鼓励那些成本效益尚未得到适当确定的预防方法。