Smith B L, Handley P, Eldredge D A
Department of Psychology and Counseling, University of Central Arkansas, Conway 72035-0001, USA.
Percept Mot Skills. 1998 Apr;86(2):723-32. doi: 10.2466/pms.1998.86.2.723.
The current study was an expansion of one by Cash, Novy, and Grant in 1994, in which responses of 101 female nursing students were examined for associations between reasons for exercise, frequency of exercise, and body-image satisfaction. In the current study, 78 male and 100 female undergraduates between the ages of 18 and 25 years (M = 21.2, SD = 1.9) from various majors completed a demographics/frequency of exercise survey, two body-assessment inventories, and the Reasons for Exercise Inventory of Silberstein, Striegel-Moore, Timko, and Rodin. Contrary to Cash, et al.'s findings, only health and fitness reasons were predictive of women's frequency of exercise, and women's dissatisfaction with specific bodily attributes was not significantly related to any reasons for exercising; however, like women in their sample, the current students who experienced more situational body dissatisfaction exercised for appearance and weight control. Sex comparisons indicated similar dissatisfaction with specific bodily attributes among men and women, but values were not significantly associated with any reasons for exercising. Women reported higher situational body dissatisfaction and exercising for appearance-related reasons more than men. Current participants may represent a more diverse group than previously tested, and the inventory's factor structure may not be generalizable to men and women.
本研究是对卡什、诺维及格兰特1994年所做研究的拓展,在他们的研究中,对101名女护生的运动原因、运动频率和身体意象满意度之间的关联进行了考察。在本研究中,来自不同专业的78名男性和100名年龄在18至25岁之间(均值 = 21.2,标准差 = 1.9)的女性本科生完成了一份人口统计学/运动频率调查问卷、两份身体评估量表以及西尔伯斯坦、斯特里格尔 - 摩尔、蒂姆科和罗丁编制的运动原因量表。与卡什等人的研究结果相反,只有健康和健身方面的原因能够预测女性的运动频率,而且女性对特定身体特征的不满与任何运动原因均无显著关联;然而,与他们样本中的女性一样,本研究中那些在情境中对身体更为不满的学生出于外表和体重控制的目的而运动。性别比较表明,男性和女性对特定身体特征的不满程度相似,但这些数值与任何运动原因均无显著关联。女性报告的情境性身体不满程度更高,且出于与外表相关的原因而运动的情况比男性更多。当前的参与者可能比之前测试的群体更加多样化,而且该量表的因子结构可能不适用于男性和女性。