Healey E C, Mallard A R, Adams M R
J Speech Hear Res. 1976 Sep;19(3):475-80. doi: 10.1044/jshr.1903.475.
This study was conducted to determine if the reduction of stuttering typically observed during singing is associated with altered vocalization or the familiarity of the melody and lyrics of the song sung by the stutterer, or both. Subjects were eight adult male stutterers. Prior to testing, each of these individuals demonstrated that he knew the melody and lyrics of a well-known song from memory. Subsequently, subjects were asked to read these lyrics aloud and then sing them. Next, subjects had to read aloud and then sing a set of unfamiliar lyrics to the conventional melody of the same song. The stutterers' reading and singing performances were audiotaped. The dependent measures of utterance duration and stuttering frequency were extracted from the tapes. Results showed that subjects' utterance durations were significantly longer during singing than reading. The main effects of singing and familiarity were both associated with significant reductions in stuttering frequency. The greatest decrement in stuttering occurred in the condition where subjects sang the familiar melody and lyrics. These findings were interpreted to mean that changes in vocalization cannot account for all of the decrease in stuttering that occurs during singing. During song, the familiarity of the melody and lyrics being produced may also affect stuttering frequency.
本研究旨在确定口吃者在唱歌时通常观察到的口吃减少现象是否与发声改变、所唱歌曲旋律和歌词的熟悉程度有关,或与两者都有关。研究对象为8名成年男性口吃者。在测试前,这些个体均表明自己能凭记忆说出一首知名歌曲的旋律和歌词。随后,要求研究对象大声朗读这些歌词,然后演唱。接下来,研究对象必须大声朗读并演唱一组与同一首歌曲传统旋律搭配的陌生歌词。口吃者的朗读和演唱表现被录音。从录音带中提取话语时长和口吃频率等相关测量数据。结果显示,研究对象唱歌时的话语时长显著长于朗读时。唱歌和熟悉程度的主效应均与口吃频率的显著降低有关。口吃减少幅度最大的情况是研究对象演唱熟悉的旋律和歌词。这些研究结果被解释为意味着发声变化不能解释唱歌时口吃减少的所有情况。在唱歌过程中,所产生的旋律和歌词的熟悉程度也可能影响口吃频率。