Seng R, Samb B, Simondon F, Cissé B, Soumaré M, Jensen H, Bennett J, Whittle H, Aaby P
INSERM U13/IMEA, Paris, France.
Pediatr Infect Dis J. 1999 Jan;18(1):48-52. doi: 10.1097/00006454-199901000-00012.
To examine whether clinical symptoms, including rash, were more common after measles immunization compared with placebo and to study the association between postvaccination symptoms and later mortality.
Examination of side effects in the 3 weeks after immunization in a trial of high titer and standard titer measles vaccines.
Two hundred twenty-four children randomly selected to be included in the surveillance for diarrhea, fever and rash.
There was no difference in fever and diarrhea between recipients of high titer vaccines and recipients of placebo. However, high titer recipients tended to have more measles-like rashes than placebo recipients [relative risk, 2.12 (range, 0.90 to 5.03)]. Among recipients of high titer vaccines, children who presented a rash had higher mortality in the following 5 to 7 years than those who did not develop rash [mortality rate ratio, 3.85 (range, 1.52 to 9.79)]. High titer recipients without a rash had the same mortality as children in the placebo group who were given standard doses of measles vaccine at 10 months of age [mortality rate, 0.76 (range, 0.35 to 1.62)].
These observations suggest that in this particular study, rash after high titer measles vaccine may identify children who received a particularly high dose of vaccine or children with more severe and persistent postvaccination immunosuppression. Whether high titer vaccine is more likely than standard titer measles vaccine to provoke such reaction is not known, given that we did not compare side effects after different titers of measles vaccine. Future trials of live measles vaccine should monitor the development of rash.
比较麻疹免疫接种后与接种安慰剂后包括皮疹在内的临床症状是否更常见,并研究接种疫苗后症状与后期死亡率之间的关联。
在一项高滴度和标准滴度麻疹疫苗试验中,对免疫接种后3周内的副作用进行检查。
随机选择224名儿童纳入腹泻、发热和皮疹监测。
高滴度疫苗接种者与安慰剂接种者在发热和腹泻方面无差异。然而,高滴度疫苗接种者出现麻疹样皮疹的情况比安慰剂接种者更多[相对风险,2.12(范围为0.90至5.03)]。在高滴度疫苗接种者中,出现皮疹的儿童在接下来的5至7年中的死亡率高于未出现皮疹的儿童[死亡率比,3.85(范围为1.52至9.79)]。没有出现皮疹的高滴度疫苗接种者的死亡率与10个月大时接种标准剂量麻疹疫苗的安慰剂组儿童相同[死亡率,0.76(范围为0.35至1.62)]。
这些观察结果表明,在这项特定研究中,高滴度麻疹疫苗接种后出现的皮疹可能表明接种了特别高剂量疫苗的儿童或接种疫苗后免疫抑制更严重且持续时间更长的儿童。鉴于我们没有比较不同滴度麻疹疫苗接种后的副作用,尚不清楚高滴度疫苗是否比标准滴度麻疹疫苗更易引发此类反应。未来的麻疹活疫苗试验应监测皮疹的发生情况。