Arthington-Skaggs B A, Jradi H, Desai T, Morrison C J
Mycotic Diseases Branch, Division of Bacterial and Mycotic Diseases, National Center for Infectious Diseases, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia 30333, USA.
J Clin Microbiol. 1999 Oct;37(10):3332-7. doi: 10.1128/JCM.37.10.3332-3337.1999.
MIC end points for the most commonly prescribed azole antifungal drug, fluconazole, can be difficult to determine because its fungistatic nature can lead to excessive "trailing" of growth during susceptibility testing by National Committee for Clinical Laboratory Standards broth macrodilution and microdilution methods. To overcome this ambiguity, and because fluconazole acts by inhibiting ergosterol biosynthesis, we developed a novel method to differentiate fluconazole-susceptible from fluconazole-resistant isolates by quantitating ergosterol production in cells grown in 0, 1, 4, 16, or 64 microg of fluconazole per ml. Ergosterol was isolated from whole yeast cells by saponification, followed by extraction of nonsaponifiable lipids with heptane. Ergosterol was identified by its unique spectrophotometric absorbance profile between 240 and 300 nm. We used this sterol quantitation method (SQM) to test 38 isolates with broth microdilution end points of </=8 microg/ml (susceptible), 16 to 32 microg/ml (susceptible dose-dependent [SDD]), or >/=64 microg/ml (resistant) and 10 isolates with trailing end points by the broth microdilution method. No significant differences in mean ergosterol content were observed between any of the isolates grown in the absence of fluconazole. However, 18 susceptible isolates showed a mean reduction in ergosterol content of 72% after exposure to 1 microg of fluconazole/ml, an 84% reduction after exposure to 4 microg/ml, and 95 and 100% reductions after exposure to 16 and 64 microg of fluconazole/ml, respectively. Ten SDD isolates showed mean ergosterol reductions of 38, 57, 73, and 99% after exposure to 1, 4, 16, and 64 microg of fluconazole/ml, respectively. In contrast, 10 resistant isolates showed mean reductions in ergosterol content of only 25, 38, 53, and 84% after exposure to the same concentrations of fluconazole. The MIC of fluconazole, by using the SQM, was defined as the lowest concentration of the drug which resulted in 80% or greater inhibition of overall mean ergosterol biosynthesis compared to that in the drug-free control. Of 38 isolates which gave clear end points by the broth microdilution method, the SQM MIC was within 2 dilutions of the broth microdilution MIC for 33 (87%). The SQM also discriminated between resistant and highly resistant isolates and was particularly useful for discerning the fluconazole susceptibilities of 10 additional isolates which gave equivocal end points by the broth microdilution method due to trailing growth. In contrast to the broth microdilution method, the SQM determined trailing isolates to be susceptible rather than resistant, indicating that the SQM may predict clinical outcome more accurately. The SQM may provide a means to enhance current methods of fluconazole susceptibility testing and may provide a better correlation of in vitro with in vivo results, particularly for isolates with trailing end points.
对于最常用的唑类抗真菌药物氟康唑而言,其最低抑菌浓度(MIC)终点可能难以确定,因为其抑菌特性可能导致在采用美国国家临床实验室标准委员会肉汤稀释法和微量稀释法进行药敏试验期间出现过度的生长“拖尾”现象。为克服这一模糊性,并且鉴于氟康唑通过抑制麦角甾醇生物合成发挥作用,我们开发了一种新方法,通过对在每毫升含0、1、4、16或64微克氟康唑的培养基中生长的细胞中的麦角甾醇生成量进行定量,来区分氟康唑敏感菌株和耐药菌株。通过皂化反应从完整酵母细胞中分离出麦角甾醇,随后用庚烷提取非皂化脂质。通过其在240至300纳米之间独特的分光光度吸收图谱鉴定麦角甾醇。我们使用这种甾醇定量方法(SQM)对38株菌株进行检测,这些菌株通过肉汤微量稀释法得出的终点浓度为≤8微克/毫升(敏感)、16至32微克/毫升(剂量依赖性敏感[SDD])或≥ ≥64微克/毫升(耐药),还对10株通过肉汤微量稀释法得出拖尾终点的菌株进行了检测。在未添加氟康唑的培养基中生长的任何菌株之间,均未观察到麦角甾醇平均含量有显著差异。然而,18株敏感菌株在暴露于每毫升1微克氟康唑后,麦角甾醇含量平均降低了72%,暴露于每毫升4微克氟康唑后降低了84% , 暴露于每毫升16和64微克氟康唑后分别降低了95%和100%。10株SDD菌株在暴露于每毫升1、4、16和64微克氟康唑后,麦角甾醇平均降低量分别为38%、57%、73%和99%。相比之下,10株耐药菌株在暴露于相同浓度的氟康唑后,麦角甾醇含量平均仅降低了25%、38%、53%和84%。通过SQM测定,氟康唑的MIC被定义为与无药对照相比,导致总体平均麦角甾醇生物合成抑制80%或更高的药物最低浓度。在通过肉汤微量稀释法得出明确终点的38株菌株中,SQM得出的MIC在肉汤微量稀释法MIC的2个稀释度范围内的有33株(87%)。SQM还区分了耐药菌株和高耐药菌株,对于辨别另外10株因拖尾生长而通过肉汤微量稀释法得出模糊终点的菌株的氟康唑敏感性特别有用。与肉汤微量稀释法不同,SQM判定拖尾菌株为敏感而非耐药,这表明SQM可能更准确地预测临床结果。SQM可能提供一种改进当前氟康唑药敏试验方法的手段,并且可能使体外结果与体内结果具有更好的相关性,特别是对于有拖尾终点的菌株。