Chatoor I, Krupnick J
Children's National Medical Center, Washington, DC 20010, USA.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2001;10 Suppl 1:I19-25. doi: 10.1007/s007870170004.
Non-specific factors refer to dimensions that are shared by most psychotherapies and include the therapeutic alliance, the therapist's competence and adherence to the treatment protocols whereas specific factors refer to the specific techniques and interventions that characterize particular psychotherapies. Review of the literature on non-specific treatment factors reveals that the therapeutic alliance and therapist competence may vary among patients and therapists, and that the therapeutic alliance also varies among treatment modalities. All three non-specific treatment factors, therapeutic alliance, therapist competence and adherence to the specific treatment modality, contribute significantly to treatment outcome and may account for more of the variance in outcome than specific treatment approach. Consequently, these factors need to be considered in the design of psychotherapy studies. In this paper we use the treatment study of infantile anorexia as an example of how to integrate these non-specific factors in the study design and the data analysis of treatment outcome in a psychotherapy study.
非特异性因素是指大多数心理治疗所共有的维度,包括治疗联盟、治疗师的能力以及对治疗方案的依从性,而特异性因素则是指特定心理治疗所特有的具体技术和干预措施。对非特异性治疗因素的文献综述表明,治疗联盟和治疗师能力在患者和治疗师之间可能存在差异,而且治疗联盟在不同治疗方式之间也有所不同。所有这三个非特异性治疗因素,即治疗联盟、治疗师能力以及对特定治疗方式的依从性,对治疗结果都有显著贡献,并且在结果差异中所占的比例可能比特定治疗方法还要大。因此,在心理治疗研究的设计中需要考虑这些因素。在本文中,我们以婴儿厌食症的治疗研究为例,说明如何在心理治疗研究的设计和治疗结果的数据分析中整合这些非特异性因素。