Babiloni F, Babiloni C, Carducci F, Romani G L, Rossini P M, Angelone L M, Cincotti F
Dipartimento di Fisiologia Umana e Farmacologia, Università di Rome La Sapienza, Italy.
Neuroimage. 2003 May;19(1):1-15. doi: 10.1016/s1053-8119(03)00052-1.
Previous simulation studies have stressed the importance of the use of fMRI priors in the estimation of cortical current density. However, no systematic variations of signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and number of electrodes were explicitly taken into account in the estimation process. In this simulation study we considered the utility of including information as estimated from fMRI. This was done by using as the dependent variable both the correlation coefficient and the relative error between the imposed and the estimated waveforms at the level of cortical region of interests (ROI). A realistic head and cortical surface model was used. Factors used in the simulations were the different values of SNR of the scalp-generated data, the different inverse operators used to estimated the cortical source activity, the strengths of the fMRI priors in the fMRI-based inverse operators, and the number of scalp electrodes used in the analysis. Analysis of variance results suggested that all the considered factors significantly afflict the correlation and the relative error between the estimated and the simulated cortical activity. For the ROIs analyzed with simulated fMRI hot spots, it was observed that the best estimation of cortical source currents was performed with the inverse operators that used fMRI information. When the ROIs analyzed do not present fMRI hot spots, both standard (i.e., minimum norm) and fMRI-based inverse operators returned statistically equivalent correlation and relative error values.
先前的模拟研究强调了在估计皮质电流密度时使用功能磁共振成像(fMRI)先验信息的重要性。然而,在估计过程中并未明确考虑信噪比(SNR)和电极数量的系统变化。在本模拟研究中,我们考虑了纳入从fMRI估计的信息的效用。这是通过将感兴趣的皮质区域(ROI)层面上施加的波形与估计的波形之间的相关系数和相对误差作为因变量来实现的。使用了逼真的头部和皮质表面模型。模拟中使用的因素包括头皮生成数据的不同SNR值、用于估计皮质源活动的不同逆算子、基于fMRI的逆算子中fMRI先验信息的强度以及分析中使用的头皮电极数量。方差分析结果表明,所有考虑的因素均显著影响估计的和模拟的皮质活动之间的相关性和相对误差。对于用模拟的fMRI热点分析的ROI,观察到使用fMRI信息的逆算子对皮质源电流进行了最佳估计。当分析的ROI不存在fMRI热点时,标准(即最小范数)和基于fMRI的逆算子返回的相关性和相对误差值在统计学上相当。