Egan Matt, Petticrew Mark, Ogilvie David, Hamilton Val
Medical Research Council Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow, 4 Lilybank Gardens, Glasgow G12 8RZ, Scotland, UK.
Am J Public Health. 2003 Sep;93(9):1463-71. doi: 10.2105/ajph.93.9.1463.
We sought to synthesize evidence of the health effects of construction of new roads by systematically reviewing observational studies of such effects. We included and critically appraised 32 studies. The review suggested that out-of-town bypasses decrease injuries on main roads through or around towns, although more robust evidence is needed on effects on secondary roads. New major urban roads have statistically insignificant effects on injury incidence. New major roads between towns decrease injuries. Out-of-town bypasses reduce disturbance and community severance in towns but increase them elsewhere. Major urban roads increase disturbance and severance. More robust research is needed in this area, particularly regarding effects of new roads on respiratory health, mental health, access to health services, and physical activity.
我们试图通过系统回顾关于新建道路健康影响的观察性研究,来综合相关证据。我们纳入并严格评估了32项研究。该综述表明,城外绕行道路可减少穿过城镇或在城镇周边的主干道上的伤害,不过对于对次要道路的影响,还需要更有力的证据。新建的主要城市道路对伤害发生率的影响在统计学上不显著。城镇之间的新建主要道路可减少伤害。城外绕行道路减少了城镇内的干扰和社区隔离,但在其他地方则增加了这些情况。主要城市道路增加了干扰和隔离。这一领域需要更有力的研究,特别是关于新建道路对呼吸健康、心理健康、获得医疗服务的机会以及身体活动的影响。