Walsh Raoul A, Tzelepis Flora
Centre for Health Research & Psycho-oncology, Cancer Council NSW, University of Newcastle, New South Wales.
Aust N Z J Public Health. 2003;27(3):310-22. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-842x.2003.tb00400.x.
To document levels of public support in Australia for smoking restrictions in licensed premises, including trends over time, and to examine the potential effects of a ban on patronage.
Systematic review of published and unpublished studies of community and staff attitudes towards smoking in bars, gaming areas and related venues were identified using Medline, Current Contents, PsycINFO and AUSTHealth prior to September 2002. State and Territory health departments, cancer organisations and branches of the National Heart Foundation were approached. Cross-sectional surveys reporting data on attitudes towards smoking restrictions and/or perceptions of effects on patronage were sought. Two reviewers assessed studies for inclusion. One extracted data using pre-coded categories with checking by the second.
Thirty-four community and seven staff surveys were synthesised qualitatively, with greater emphasis given to surveys using random selection. All surveys conducted since 1993, which included the separate smoking area response option, have demonstrated majority support for some form of smoking restriction on licensed premises. From 2000, surveys with the ban option alone report majority support for prohibiting smoking completely in bars (52-68%) and gaming areas (64-76%). Support increased significantly after the Sharp damages award. Customer preference data indicate banning smoking is most likely to have a neutral or positive effect on patronage.
Support for a ban on smoking in licensed premises has increased by almost 20% in the past decade. State and Territory governments should introduce legislation banning smoking in all indoor drinking and gaming areas immediately.
记录澳大利亚公众对在持牌场所实施吸烟限制的支持程度,包括随时间的趋势,并研究禁令对光顾率的潜在影响。
2002年9月之前,通过医学期刊数据库(Medline)、《现刊目次》(Current Contents)、心理学文摘数据库(PsycINFO)和澳大利亚健康数据库(AUSTHealth),系统回顾已发表和未发表的关于社区及工作人员对酒吧、博彩区及相关场所吸烟态度的研究。与州和地区卫生部门、癌症组织以及国家心脏基金会的分支机构进行了沟通。寻求报告有关对吸烟限制态度和/或对光顾率影响认知数据的横断面调查。两名评审员评估研究是否纳入。一名评审员使用预编码类别提取数据,由另一名进行核对。
对34项社区调查和7项工作人员调查进行了定性综合分析,更侧重于随机抽样的调查。自1993年以来进行的所有调查(包括单独的吸烟区回应选项)都表明,大多数人支持对持牌场所实施某种形式的吸烟限制。从2000年起,仅设有禁令选项的调查显示,大多数人支持在酒吧(52%-68%)和博彩区(64%-76%)完全禁止吸烟。在夏普损害赔偿裁决之后,支持率显著上升。顾客偏好数据表明,禁止吸烟最有可能对光顾率产生中性或积极影响。
在过去十年中,对在持牌场所禁烟的支持率上升了近20%。州和地区政府应立即出台立法,禁止在所有室内饮酒和博彩区域吸烟。