O'Neill Ciaran, Lutman Mark E, Archbold Sue M, Gregory Sue, Nikolopoulos Thomas P
School of Policy Studies, University of Ulster, Jordanstown, Newtownabbey, BT37 0QB, UK.
Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol. 2004 Feb;68(2):149-60. doi: 10.1016/j.ijporl.2003.09.015.
To test the reliability of a validated closed-format questionnaire assessing parental views following cochlear implantation of their child.
Parents were surveyed using a closed-format questionnaire developed in earlier work. The same parents were surveyed 1 month later and responses compared. Test-retest reliability was thereby assessed.
Tertiary referral Pediatric Cochlear Implant Centre in the UK.
The parents of 20 children who had been born deaf or were deafened by age 3 years and who had been implanted for at least 2 years were drawn at random from patient lists. Parents were surveyed using a closed-format questionnaire whose validity had been previously assessed and re-surveyed 1 month later. Responses over time were compared.
For the majority of items in the questionnaire, the replication of the item would lead to the same response on at least 95% of occasions. The text of the closed-format questionnaire is reproduced in full.
This validated closed-format questionnaire appears to be unique in respect of cochlear implantation, being based explicitly on issues thought important by the parents. The high test-retest reliability indicates that it is capable of eliciting parental views in a meaningful manner. This information that is not currently available by other means can then be used as part of an overall assessment of outcomes, to inform efforts aimed at quality improvement as well as demonstrating accountability to purchasers and policymakers. Moreover, a wider use of this instrument can result in valid comparisons of outcomes among different cochlear implant centres.
测试一份经过验证的封闭式问卷评估儿童人工耳蜗植入术后家长观点的可靠性。
使用早期研究中开发的封闭式问卷对家长进行调查。1个月后对相同的家长再次进行调查,并比较两次的回答。由此评估重测信度。
英国一家三级转诊儿科人工耳蜗植入中心。
从患者名单中随机抽取20名出生即耳聋或3岁前致聋且已植入人工耳蜗至少2年的儿童的家长。使用一份效度先前已评估过的封闭式问卷对家长进行调查,并在1个月后再次调查。比较不同时间的回答。
对于问卷中的大多数项目,重复该项目至少95%的情况下会得到相同的回答。封闭式问卷全文如下。
这份经过验证的封闭式问卷在人工耳蜗植入方面似乎独具特色,它明确基于家长认为重要的问题。较高的重测信度表明它能够以有意义的方式引出家长的观点。这些目前通过其他方式无法获得的信息可作为总体结果评估的一部分,为质量改进工作提供信息,并向购买者和政策制定者证明责任所在。此外,更广泛地使用该工具可以对不同人工耳蜗植入中心的结果进行有效的比较。