Oertel Matthias, Boscardin W John, Obrist Walter D, Glenn Thomas C, McArthur David L, Gravori Tooraj, Lee Jae Hong, Martin Neil A
Department of Biostatistics, Brain Injury Research Center, David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California at Los Angeles, California 90095-7039, USA.
J Neurosurg. 2005 Nov;103(5):812-24. doi: 10.3171/jns.2005.103.5.0812.
The purpose of this prospective study was to evaluate the cumulative incidence, duration, and time course of cerebral vasospasm after traumatic brain injury (TBI) in a cohort of 299 patients.
Transcranial Doppler (TCD) ultrasonography studies of blood flow velocity in the middle cerebral and basilar arteries (VMCA and VBA, respectively) were performed at regular intervals during the first 2 weeks posttrauma in association with 133Xe cerebral blood flow (CBF) measurements. According to current definitions of vasospasm, five different criteria were used to classify the patients: A (VMCA > 120 cm/second); B (VMCA > 120 cm/second and a Lindegaard ratio [LR] > 3); C (spasm index [SI] in the anterior circulation > 3.4); D (VBA > 90 cm/second); and E (SI in the posterior circulation > 2.5). Criteria C and E were considered to represent hemodynamically significant vasospasm. Mixed-effects spline models were used to analyze the data of multiple measurements with an inconsistent sampling rate. Overall 45.2% of the patients demonstrated at least one criterion for vasospasm. The patients in whom vasospasm developed were significantly younger and had lower Glasgow Coma Scale scores on admission. The normalized cumulative incidences were 36.9 and 36.2% for patients with Criteria A and B, respectively. Hemodynamically significant vasospasm in the anterior circulation (Criterion C) was found in 44.6% of the patients, whereas vasospasm in the BA-Criterion D or E-was found in only 19 and 22.5% of the patients, respectively. The most common day of onset for Criteria A, B, D, and E was postinjury Day 2. The highest risk of developing hemodynamically significant vasospasm in the anterior circulation was found on Day 3. The daily prevalence of vasospasm in patients in the intensive care unit was 30% from postinjury Day 2 to Day 13. Vasospasm resolved after a duration of 5 days in 50% of the patients with Criterion A or B and after a period of 3.5 days in 50% of those patients with Criterion D or E. Hemodynamically significant vasospasm in the anterior circulation resolved after 2.5 days in 50% of the patients. The time course of that vasospasm was primarily determined by a decrease in CBF.
The incidence of vasospasm after TBI is similar to that following aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage. Because vasospasm is a significant event in a high proportion of patients after severe head injury, close TCD and CBF monitoring is recommended for the treatment of such patients.
本前瞻性研究旨在评估299例创伤性脑损伤(TBI)患者脑血管痉挛的累积发生率、持续时间及时间进程。
在创伤后的前2周内定期进行经颅多普勒(TCD)超声检查,测量大脑中动脉和基底动脉(分别为VMCA和VBA)的血流速度,并结合133Xe脑血流量(CBF)测量。根据目前血管痉挛的定义,采用五种不同标准对患者进行分类:A(VMCA>120 cm/秒);B(VMCA>120 cm/秒且林德加德比值[LR]>3);C(前循环痉挛指数[SI]>3.4);D(VBA>90 cm/秒);E(后循环SI>2.5)。标准C和E被认为代表血流动力学显著的血管痉挛。使用混合效应样条模型分析采样率不一致的多次测量数据。总体而言,45.2%的患者至少符合一项血管痉挛标准。发生血管痉挛的患者明显更年轻,入院时格拉斯哥昏迷量表评分更低。符合标准A和B的患者标准化累积发生率分别为36.9%和36.2%。44.6%的患者在前循环中发现血流动力学显著的血管痉挛(标准C),而在基底动脉中符合标准D或E的血管痉挛分别仅在19%和22.5%的患者中发现。标准A、B、D和E最常见的发病日为伤后第2天。在前循环中发生血流动力学显著血管痉挛的最高风险出现在第3天。从伤后第2天到第13天,重症监护病房患者血管痉挛的每日患病率为30%。符合标准A或B的患者中,50%的患者血管痉挛在持续5天后缓解,符合标准D或E的患者中,50%的患者在3.5天后缓解。前循环中血流动力学显著的血管痉挛在50%的患者中2.5天后缓解。该血管痉挛的时间进程主要由CBF降低决定。
TBI后血管痉挛的发生率与动脉瘤性蛛网膜下腔出血后的发生率相似。由于血管痉挛在重度颅脑损伤后相当比例的患者中是一个重要事件,建议对这类患者进行密切的TCD和CBF监测以进行治疗。