Elashoff Robert M, Li Gang, Li Ning
Department of Biostatistics, School of Public Health, University of California at Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Stat Med. 2007 Jun 30;26(14):2813-35. doi: 10.1002/sim.2749.
Joint analysis of longitudinal measurements and survival data has received much attention in recent years. However, previous work has primarily focused on a single failure type for the event time. In this paper we consider joint modelling of repeated measurements and competing risks failure time data to allow for more than one distinct failure type in the survival endpoint which occurs frequently in clinical trials. Our model uses latent random variables and common covariates to link together the sub-models for the longitudinal measurements and competing risks failure time data, respectively. An EM-based algorithm is derived to obtain the parameter estimates, and a profile likelihood method is proposed to estimate their standard errors. Our method enables one to make joint inference on multiple outcomes which is often necessary in analyses of clinical trials. Furthermore, joint analysis has several advantages compared with separate analysis of either the longitudinal data or competing risks survival data. By modelling the event time, the analysis of longitudinal measurements is adjusted to allow for non-ignorable missing data due to informative dropout, which cannot be appropriately handled by the standard linear mixed effects models alone. In addition, the joint model utilizes information from both outcomes, and could be substantially more efficient than the separate analysis of the competing risk survival data as shown in our simulation study. The performance of our method is evaluated and compared with separate analyses using both simulated data and a clinical trial for the scleroderma lung disease.
近年来,纵向测量数据与生存数据的联合分析受到了广泛关注。然而,以往的工作主要集中在事件时间的单一失败类型上。在本文中,我们考虑重复测量数据与竞争风险失败时间数据的联合建模,以便在生存终点中纳入不止一种不同的失败类型,这种情况在临床试验中经常出现。我们的模型使用潜在随机变量和共同协变量,分别将纵向测量数据的子模型与竞争风险失败时间数据的子模型联系起来。我们推导了一种基于期望最大化(EM)的算法来获得参数估计值,并提出了一种轮廓似然方法来估计其标准误差。我们的方法能够对多个结果进行联合推断,这在临床试验分析中通常是必要的。此外,与单独分析纵向数据或竞争风险生存数据相比,联合分析具有几个优点。通过对事件时间进行建模,纵向测量的分析得到了调整,以考虑因信息删失导致的不可忽略的缺失数据,而仅靠标准线性混合效应模型无法妥善处理这些数据。此外,联合模型利用了来自两个结果的信息,并且如我们的模拟研究所示,可能比单独分析竞争风险生存数据更有效。我们评估了我们方法的性能,并与使用模拟数据和硬皮病肺病临床试验数据的单独分析进行了比较。