Metsios Giorgos S, Flouris Andreas D, Koutedakis Yiannis, Nevill Allan
Institute of Human Performance and Rehabilitation, Greece.
J Sci Med Sport. 2008 Apr;11(2):214-7. doi: 10.1016/j.jsams.2006.12.120. Epub 2007 Jun 4.
We assessed validity and reliability of the new 20m square shuttle run test (SST) for predicting maximal oxygen uptake (V O(2max)) and compared it with its predecessor, the 20m Multistage Shuttle Run Test (MST). In a repeated-measures randomised-block design, 74 healthy adult males performed the SST, the MST and a treadmill test (TT). To assess reliability, 40 of the total 74 volunteers were randomly-selected to perform the SST and MST twice. Unlike the SST (p>0.05), mean predicted V O(2max)(V predO(2max)) from the MST was significantly increased from that measured during the TT (p<0.05). The V predO(2max) from SST and MST correlated with TT V O(2max) at r=0.95 (p<0.001) and r=0.63 (p<0.001), respectively. Prediction error of SST was -0.3+/-3.3mlkg(-1)min(-1) with a coefficient of variation of +/-3.5%, while the equivalent values for MST were 4.2+/-7.3mlkg(-1)min(-1) and +/-7.4%. Mean test-retest V predO(2max) did not differ for both SST and MST (p>0.05), while the corresponding test-retest correlation coefficients were r=0.85 (p<0.001) and r=0.72 (p<0.001). Reliability errors in 95% limits of agreement were 0.3+/-4.8 and 0.6+/-6.8mlkg(-1)min(-1) while coefficients of variation were +/-5.2% and +/-6.8% for the SST and MST, respectively. It is concluded that SST is a more valid proxy than MST for predicting laboratory V O(2max) based on the current procedures, while both tests are sufficiently reliable in healthy male adults.
我们评估了新型20米正方形往返跑测试(SST)预测最大摄氧量(V O(2max))的有效性和可靠性,并将其与其前身20米多级往返跑测试(MST)进行比较。在重复测量随机区组设计中,74名健康成年男性进行了SST、MST和跑步机测试(TT)。为评估可靠性,从74名志愿者中随机选取40人进行SST和MST各两次。与SST不同(p>0.05),MST的平均预测V O(2max)(V predO(2max))显著高于TT测量值(p<0.05)。SST和MST的V predO(2max)与TT的V O(2max)的相关性分别为r=0.95(p<0.001)和r=0.63(p<0.001)。SST的预测误差为-0.3±3.3mlkg(-1)min(-1),变异系数为±3.5%,而MST的相应值为4.2±7.3mlkg(-1)min(-1)和±7.4%。SST和MST的平均重测V predO(2max)无差异(p>0.05),而相应的重测相关系数分别为r=0.85(p<0.001)和r=0.72(p<0.001)。SST和MST在95%一致性界限内的可靠性误差分别为0.3±4.8和0.6±6.8mlkg(-1)min(-1),变异系数分别为±5.2%和±6.8%。结论是,基于当前程序,SST在预测实验室V O(2max)方面比MST更有效,而两种测试在健康成年男性中都具有足够的可靠性。