Rao Shobha, Gokhale Medha, Kanade Asawari
Agharkar Research Institute, GG Agarkar Road, Pune 411004, India.
Public Health Nutr. 2008 Feb;11(2):142-50. doi: 10.1017/S1368980007000055. Epub 2007 Jun 13.
In view of the paucity of data on energy costs, the present study aimed to estimate these for typical daily activities performed by women in rural India.
A cross-sectional study covering 26 different activities was done by indirect calorimetry using the Oxylog instrument (Morgan).
Villages about 30-40 km from Pune city, Maharashtra, India.
Energy costs were measured on 22 rural Indian women aged 18-45 years.
Irrespective of whether an activity was domestic or farming, energy cost was lower when performed in sitting position (cleaning grains 5.24 kJ min-1, plucking leafy vegetables 5.76 kJ min-1) and increased considerably with the extent of muscular movement (carrying two water containers 14.77 kJ min-1, chopping firewood 14.5 kJ min-1), indicating the importance of the postural details of the activity. Physical activity ratio computed using the Food and Agriculture Organization/World Health Organization/United Nations University equation (PARw) was lower for all activities compared with that (PARm) based on measured basal metabolic rate, indicating the need for a population-specific equation. Furthermore, PARw identified more activities as belonging to the 'very light' category (nine out of 26 activities), in contrast to the perception of rural women which was supported with empirical evidence. Estimated daily energy expenditure of the women was 7.69 +/- 0.63 MJ (1837 +/- 150 kcal) and identified their daily activity pattern as 'moderate' based on PALw (1.65 +/- 0.16) while PALm (2.04 +/- 0.18) identified it as 'heavy'.
Our results highlight the importance of qualitative descriptions of the various activities. The energy costs for several daily activities reported in this study could potentially be used for estimating daily energy expenditure of women from similar rural settings.
鉴于能源成本数据匮乏,本研究旨在估算印度农村女性日常典型活动的能源成本。
采用间接测热法,使用Oxylog仪器(摩根公司)对26种不同活动进行横断面研究。
印度马哈拉施特拉邦浦那市约30 - 40公里外的村庄。
对22名年龄在18 - 45岁的印度农村女性的能源成本进行了测量。
无论活动是家务还是农事,坐着进行时能源成本较低(清理谷物5.24千焦/分钟,采摘叶菜类蔬菜5.76千焦/分钟),且随着肌肉运动量的增加大幅上升(搬运两个水桶14.77千焦/分钟,砍柴14.5千焦/分钟),这表明活动姿势细节的重要性。使用粮农组织/世界卫生组织/联合国大学公式(PARw)计算的体力活动比率,与基于实测基础代谢率计算的比率(PARm)相比,所有活动的该比率都更低,这表明需要一个针对特定人群的公式。此外,PARw将更多活动归类为“极轻”类别(26项活动中有9项),这与农村女性的认知不同,而农村女性的认知得到了实证证据的支持。这些女性的估计每日能量消耗为7.69±0.63兆焦(1837±150千卡),基于PALw(1.65±0.16)将她们的日常活动模式确定为“中等”,而PALm(2.04±0.18)则将其确定为“重度”。
我们的结果凸显了对各种活动进行定性描述的重要性。本研究报告的几项日常活动的能源成本可能可用于估算类似农村环境中女性的每日能量消耗。