Division of General Medicine and Primary Care, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2008 Aug;23(8):1187-93. doi: 10.1007/s11606-008-0628-7. Epub 2008 May 14.
Completing pre-transplant evaluations may be a greater barrier to renal transplantation for blacks with end-stage renal disease (ESRD) than for whites.
To determine whether social support networks facilitate completing the pre-transplant evaluation and reduce racial disparities in this aspect of care.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: We surveyed 742 black and white ESRD patients in four regional networks 9 months after they initiated dialysis in 1996 and 1997. Patients reported instrumental support networks (number of friends or family to help with daily activities), emotional support networks (number of friends or family available for counsel on personal problems) and dialysis center support (support from dialysis center staff and patients). The completion of pre-transplant evaluations, including preoperative risk stratification and testing, was determined by medical record reviews.
Complete renal pre-transplant evaluations.
Compared to patients with low levels of instrumental support, those with high levels were more likely to have complete evaluations (25% versus 46%, respectively, p < .001). In adjusted analyses, high levels of instrumental support were associated with higher rates of complete evaluations among black women (p < .05), white women (p < .05), and white men (p < .05), but not black men. Among black men, but not other groups, private insurance was a significant predictor of complete evaluations.
Instrumental support networks may facilitate completing renal pre-transplant evaluations. Clinical interventions that supplement instrumental support should be evaluated to improve access to renal transplantation. Access to supplemental insurance may also promote complete evaluations for black patients.
对于终末期肾病(ESRD)的黑人患者来说,完成移植前评估可能比白人患者面临更大的障碍。
确定社会支持网络是否有助于完成移植前评估,并减少这方面护理的种族差异。
设计、地点和参与者:我们在 1996 年和 1997 年对四个区域网络中的 742 名黑人和白人 ESRD 患者进行了调查,这些患者在开始透析后 9 个月接受了调查。患者报告了工具性支持网络(帮助进行日常活动的朋友或家人的数量)、情感支持网络(可在个人问题上提供咨询的朋友或家人的数量)和透析中心支持(透析中心工作人员和患者的支持)。通过病历回顾确定了移植前评估的完成情况,包括术前风险分层和检测。
完成完整的肾脏移植前评估。
与工具性支持水平较低的患者相比,高水平的患者更有可能完成评估(分别为 25%和 46%,p<0.001)。在调整分析中,高水平的工具性支持与黑人女性(p<0.05)、白人女性(p<0.05)和白人男性(p<0.05)完成完整评估的比率较高相关,但与黑人男性无关。在黑人男性中,但在其他群体中,私人保险是完成评估的一个重要预测因素。
工具性支持网络可能有助于完成肾脏移植前评估。应评估补充工具性支持的临床干预措施,以改善接受肾脏移植的机会。补充保险的获得也可能促进黑人患者的完整评估。