Kovelman Ioulia, Shalinsky Mark H, White Katherine S, Schmitt Shawn N, Berens Melody S, Paymer Nora, Petitto Laura-Ann
Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, MA, USA.
Brain Lang. 2009 May-Jun;109(2-3):112-23. doi: 10.1016/j.bandl.2008.09.008. Epub 2008 Oct 30.
The brain basis of bilinguals' ability to use two languages at the same time has been a hotly debated topic. On the one hand, behavioral research has suggested that bilingual dual language use involves complex and highly principled linguistic processes. On the other hand, brain-imaging research has revealed that bilingual language switching involves neural activations in brain areas dedicated to general executive functions not specific to language processing, such as general task maintenance. Here we address the involvement of language-specific versus cognitive-general brain mechanisms for bilingual language processing. We study a unique population, bimodal bilinguals proficient in signed and spoken languages, and we use an innovative brain-imaging technology, functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS; Hitachi ETG-4000). Like fMRI, the fNIRS technology measures hemodynamic change, but it is also advanced in permitting movement for unconstrained speech and sign production. Participant groups included (i) hearing ASL-English bilinguals, (ii) ASL monolinguals, and (iii) English monolinguals. Imaging tasks included picture naming in "Monolingual mode" (using one language at a time) and in "Bilingual mode" (using both languages either simultaneously or in rapid alternation). Behavioral results revealed that accuracy was similar among groups and conditions. By contrast, neuroimaging results revealed that bilinguals in Bilingual mode showed greater signal intensity within posterior temporal regions ("Wernicke's area") than in Monolingual mode.
Bilinguals' ability to use two languages effortlessly and without confusion involves the use of language-specific posterior temporal brain regions. This research with both fNIRS and bimodal bilinguals sheds new light on the extent and variability of brain tissue that underlies language processing, and addresses the tantalizing questions of how language modality, sign and speech, impact language representation in the 7 brain.
双语者同时使用两种语言的大脑基础一直是一个备受争议的话题。一方面,行为研究表明,双语者的双语使用涉及复杂且高度有原则的语言过程。另一方面,脑成像研究表明,双语语言切换涉及大脑中专门负责一般执行功能而非特定语言处理的区域的神经激活,比如一般任务维持。在这里,我们探讨双语语言处理中特定语言与认知通用大脑机制的参与情况。我们研究了一个独特的群体,即精通手语和口语的双峰双语者,并使用了一种创新的脑成像技术,即功能近红外光谱技术(fNIRS;日立ETG - 4000)。与功能磁共振成像(fMRI)一样,fNIRS技术测量血液动力学变化,但它在允许进行无约束的言语和手语表达的运动方面也更先进。参与者群体包括:(i)听力正常的美国手语 - 英语双语者,(ii)美国手语单语者,以及(iii)英语单语者。成像任务包括在“单语模式”(一次使用一种语言)和“双语模式”(同时或快速交替使用两种语言)下的图片命名。行为结果显示,各群体和条件下的准确性相似。相比之下,神经成像结果显示,处于双语模式的双语者在颞叶后部区域(“韦尼克区”)的信号强度比单语模式下更大。
双语者轻松且无混淆地使用两种语言的能力涉及特定语言的颞叶后部脑区的使用。这项使用fNIRS和双峰双语者的研究为语言处理背后的脑组织范围和变异性提供了新的见解,并解决了语言模态(手语和言语)如何影响大脑中语言表征这一诱人问题。