Danziger Zachary, Fishbach Alon, Mussa-Ivaldi Ferdinando A
Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, USA.
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2009 May;56(5):1502-11. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2009.2013822. Epub 2009 Feb 6.
The goal of this study is to create and examine machine learning algorithms that adapt in a controlled and cadenced way to foster a harmonious learning environment between the user and the controlled device. To evaluate these algorithms, we have developed a simple experimental framework. Subjects wear an instrumented data glove that records finger motions. The high-dimensional glove signals remotely control the joint angles of a simulated planar two-link arm on a computer screen, which is used to acquire targets. A machine learning algorithm was applied to adaptively change the transformation between finger motion and the simulated robot arm. This algorithm was either LMS gradient descent or the Moore-Penrose (MP) pseudoinverse transformation. Both algorithms modified the glove-to-joint angle map so as to reduce the endpoint errors measured in past performance. The MP group performed worse than the control group (subjects not exposed to any machine learning), while the LMS group outperformed the control subjects. However, the LMS subjects failed to achieve better generalization than the control subjects, and after extensive training converged to the same level of performance as the control subjects. These results highlight the limitations of coadaptive learning using only endpoint error reduction.
本研究的目标是创建并检验以可控且有节奏的方式进行自适应的机器学习算法,以营造用户与受控设备之间和谐的学习环境。为评估这些算法,我们开发了一个简单的实验框架。受试者佩戴一个记录手指动作的仪器化数据手套。高维手套信号远程控制计算机屏幕上模拟平面双连杆臂的关节角度,该双连杆臂用于获取目标。应用机器学习算法来自适应地改变手指动作与模拟机器人手臂之间的变换。此算法要么是最小均方(LMS)梯度下降算法,要么是摩尔-彭罗斯(MP)伪逆变换算法。两种算法都修改了手套到关节角度的映射,以减少在过去表现中测得的端点误差。MP组的表现比对照组(未接触任何机器学习的受试者)更差,而LMS组的表现优于对照受试者。然而,LMS组的受试者未能比对照受试者实现更好的泛化,并且在经过大量训练后,收敛到与对照受试者相同的表现水平。这些结果凸显了仅使用端点误差减少进行协同自适应学习的局限性。