Messier Virginie, Rabasa-Lhoret Rémi, Doucet Eric, Brochu Martin, Lavoie Jean-Marc, Karelis Antony, Prud'homme Denis, Strychar Irene
Department of Nutrition, University of Montreal, 110 Avenue des Pins Ouest, Montreal, Quebec, Canada.
J Sports Sci. 2010 Jan;28(1):83-92. doi: 10.1080/02640410903390105.
The aim of this study was to examine the effects of the addition of a resistance training programme to a caloric restriction weight loss intervention on psychosocial profile. The study sample consisted of 137 overweight and obese post-menopausal women. Participants were randomized to a caloric restriction group and caloric restriction + resistance training group. Psychosocial, anthropometric, and metabolic variables were measured before and after the 6-month weight loss intervention. Both groups presented similar weight loss and there were no significant differences between the caloric restriction group and caloric restriction + resistance training group for changes in psychosocial profile. Thereafter, all participants were classified into quintiles based on the amount of weight loss. In all quintiles, women markedly improved body esteem and self-esteem, and decreased hunger and perceived risk for diabetes mellitus (P < 0.05). However, significant increases in dietary restraint were observed in quintiles 2-5 (> or =2.4 % body weight loss), decreases in disinhibition in quintiles 3-5 (> or =4.9 %), increases in self-efficacy in quintiles 3-5 (> or =4.9 %), and increases in health perceptions in quintile 5 (> or =11.1%). The results of this study do not support the hypothesis that the addition of a resistance training programme to a caloric restriction weight loss intervention has additional benefits on psychosocial profile. Overall, the significant improvements in the psychosocial profile observed were mostly accounted for by the degree of weight loss.
本研究的目的是检验在热量限制减肥干预中加入阻力训练计划对心理社会状况的影响。研究样本包括137名超重和肥胖的绝经后女性。参与者被随机分为热量限制组和热量限制+阻力训练组。在为期6个月的减肥干预前后,测量心理社会、人体测量和代谢变量。两组的体重减轻情况相似,热量限制组和热量限制+阻力训练组在心理社会状况变化方面没有显著差异。此后,所有参与者根据体重减轻量被分为五分位数。在所有五分位数中,女性的身体自尊和自尊显著改善,饥饿感和糖尿病感知风险降低(P<0.05)。然而,在第2-5五分位数(体重减轻≥2.4%)中观察到饮食克制显著增加,在第3-5五分位数(体重减轻≥4.9%)中去抑制减少,在第3-5五分位数(体重减轻≥4.9%)中自我效能增加,在第5五分位数(体重减轻≥11.1%)中健康认知增加。本研究结果不支持在热量限制减肥干预中加入阻力训练计划对心理社会状况有额外益处的假设。总体而言,观察到的心理社会状况的显著改善主要是由体重减轻程度所致。