Eren-Oruklu Meriyan, Cinar Ali, Quinn Lauretta
Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Illinois Institute of Technology, Chicago, Illinois, USA.
J Diabetes Sci Technol. 2010 Jan 1;4(1):25-33. doi: 10.1177/193229681000400104.
Avoiding hypoglycemia while keeping glucose within the narrow normoglycemic range (70-120 mg/dl) is a major challenge for patients with type 1 diabetes. Continuous glucose monitors can provide hypoglycemic alarms when the measured glucose decreases below a threshold. However, a better approach is to provide an early alarm that predicts a hypoglycemic episode before it occurs, allowing enough time for the patient to take the necessary precaution to avoid hypoglycemia.
We have previously proposed subject-specific recursive models for the prediction of future glucose concentrations and evaluated their prediction performance. In this work, our objective was to evaluate this algorithm further to predict hypoglycemia and provide early hypoglycemic alarms. Three different methods were proposed for alarm decision, where (A) absolute predicted glucose values, (B) cumulative-sum (CUSUM) control chart, and (C) exponentially weighted moving-average (EWMA) control chart were used. Each method was validated using data from the Diabetes Research in Children Network, which consist of measurements from a continuous glucose sensor during an insulin-induced hypoglycemia. Reference serum glucose measurements were used to determine the sensitivity to predict hypoglycemia and the false alarm rate.
With the hypoglycemic threshold set to 60 mg/dl, sensitivity of 89, 87.5, and 89% and specificity of 67, 74, and 78% were reported for methods A, B, and C, respectively. Mean values for time to detection were 30 +/- 5.51 (A), 25.8 +/- 6.46 (B), and 27.7 +/- 5.32 (C) minutes.
Compared to the absolute value method, both CUSUM and EWMA methods behaved more conservatively before raising an alarm (reduced time to detection), which significantly decreased the false alarm rate and increased the specificity.
对于1型糖尿病患者而言,在将血糖维持在较窄的正常血糖范围(70 - 120毫克/分升)内的同时避免低血糖是一项重大挑战。当测得的血糖降至阈值以下时,连续血糖监测仪可发出低血糖警报。然而,更好的方法是在低血糖发作之前提供早期警报,以便患者有足够时间采取必要预防措施来避免低血糖。
我们之前提出了针对个体的递归模型来预测未来血糖浓度,并评估了它们的预测性能。在这项工作中,我们的目标是进一步评估该算法以预测低血糖并提供早期低血糖警报。提出了三种不同的警报决策方法,其中(A)使用绝对预测血糖值,(B)使用累积和(CUSUM)控制图,(C)使用指数加权移动平均(EWMA)控制图。每种方法都使用儿童糖尿病研究网络的数据进行了验证,该数据包括胰岛素诱导低血糖期间连续血糖传感器的测量值。参考血清葡萄糖测量值用于确定预测低血糖的敏感性和误报率。
将低血糖阈值设定为60毫克/分升时,方法A、B和C报告的敏感性分别为89%、87.5%和89%,特异性分别为67%、74%和78%。检测时间的平均值分别为30 ± 5.51(A)、25.8 ± 6.46(B)和27.7 ± 5.32(C)分钟。
与绝对值方法相比,CUSUM和EWMA方法在发出警报之前表现得更为保守(检测时间缩短),这显著降低了误报率并提高了特异性。