Davey Jeremy D, Freeman James E
Centre for Accident Research and Road Safety, Institute of Health and Biological Innovation, Queensland University of Technology, Australia.
Sultan Qaboos Univ Med J. 2011 Feb;11(1):29-37. Epub 2011 Feb 12.
The efficacy of road safety countermeasures to deter motorists from engaging in illegal behaviours is extremely important when considering the personal and economic impact of road accidents on the community. In many countries, deterrence theory has remained a cornerstone of criminology and criminal justice policy, particularly within the field of road safety, as policy makers and enforcement agencies attempt to increase perceptions regarding the certainty, severity and swiftness of sanctions for those who engage in illegal motoring behaviours. Using the Australian experience (particularly the tremendous amount of research into drink driving), the current paper reviews the principles underpinning deterrence theory, the utilisation of the approach within some contemporary road safety initiatives (e.g., random breath testing) as well as highlighting some methods to enhance a deterrent effect. The paper also provides direction for future deterrence-based research, in particular, considering the powerful impact of non-legal sanctions, punishment avoidance as well as creating culturally embedded behavioural change.
在考虑道路交通事故对社区造成的人身和经济影响时,道路安全对策对于阻止驾车者从事非法行为的功效极为重要。在许多国家,威慑理论一直是犯罪学和刑事司法政策的基石,尤其是在道路安全领域,因为政策制定者和执法机构试图提高人们对于对从事非法驾车行为者实施制裁的确定性、严厉性和迅速性的认知。本文以澳大利亚的经验(特别是对酒后驾车的大量研究)为例,回顾了支撑威慑理论的原则、该方法在一些当代道路安全举措(如随机呼气测试)中的应用,并着重介绍了一些增强威慑效果的方法。本文还为未来基于威慑的研究提供了方向,特别是考虑到非法律制裁、避免惩罚以及促成文化层面行为改变的强大影响。