Department of Cognitive Neuroscience, Faculty of Psychology and Neuroscience, Maastricht University, UNS 40, 6229 ER, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Neuroimage. 2012 Jan 16;59(2):1369-81. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2011.08.035. Epub 2011 Aug 19.
The central question of the relationship between structure and function in the human brain is still not well understood. In order to investigate this fundamental relationship we create functional probabilistic maps from a large set of mapping experiments and compare the location of functionally localised regions across subjects using different whole-brain alignment schemes. To avoid the major problems associated with meta-analysis approaches, all subjects are scanned using the same paradigms, the same scanner and the same analysis pipeline. We show that an advanced, curvature driven cortex based alignment (CBA) scheme largely removes macro-anatomical variability across subjects. Remaining variability in the observed spatial location of functional regions, thus, reflects the "true" functional variability, i.e. the quantified variability is a good estimator of the underlying structural-functional correspondence. After localising 13 widely studied functional areas, we found a large variability in the degree to which functional areas respect macro-anatomical boundaries across the cortex. Some areas, such as the frontal eye fields (FEF) are strongly bound to a macro-anatomical location. Fusiform face area (FFA) on the other hand, varies in its location along the length of the fusiform gyrus even though the gyri themselves are well aligned across subjects. Language areas were found to vary greatly across subjects whilst a high degree of overlap was observed in sensory and motor areas. The observed differences in functional variability for different specialised areas suggest that a more complete estimation of the structure-function relationship across the whole cortex requires further empirical studies with an expanded test battery.
人脑结构与功能之间的关系这一核心问题仍未得到很好的理解。为了研究这种基本关系,我们从大量的映射实验中创建了功能概率图,并使用不同的全脑对齐方案比较了跨主题的功能局部化区域的位置。为避免与元分析方法相关的主要问题,所有受试者均使用相同的范式、相同的扫描仪和相同的分析管道进行扫描。我们表明,先进的基于曲率的皮层对齐(CBA)方案在很大程度上消除了跨受试者的宏观解剖变异性。因此,在观察到的功能区域的空间位置中存在的剩余变异性反映了“真实”的功能变异性,即量化的变异性是结构-功能对应关系的良好估计。在定位了 13 个广泛研究的功能区域之后,我们发现功能区域在多大程度上尊重皮层的宏观解剖边界方面存在很大的变异性。有些区域,例如额眼区(FEF),与宏观解剖位置紧密相关。另一方面,梭状回面孔区(FFA)尽管在受试者之间的梭状回本身很好地对齐,但在梭状回的长度上其位置变化。语言区在受试者之间差异很大,而在感觉和运动区观察到高度重叠。不同专门区域的功能变异性的观察到的差异表明,需要进一步的实证研究和扩展的测试组合,才能更全面地估计整个皮层的结构-功能关系。