Department of Neurology & Neurosurgery, McGill University, Montreal, QC, H3W 1E4 Canada.
Brain Cogn. 2012 Jul;79(2):159-79. doi: 10.1016/j.bandc.2012.02.006. Epub 2012 Mar 30.
Putatively safe and effective for improving cognitive performance in both health and disease, products purported to train the brain appeal to consumers and healthcare practitioners. In an increasingly health-centered society, these applications constitute a burgeoning commercial market. Sparse evidence coupled with lack of scientific rigor, however, leaves claims concerning the impact and duration of such brain training largely unsubstantiated. On the other hand, at least some scientific findings seem to support the effectiveness and sustainability of training for higher brain functions such as attention and working memory. In the present paper we provide a tectonic integration and synthesis of cognitive training approaches. Specifically, we sketch the relative merits and shortcomings of these programs, which often appeal to parents who must choose between side-effect-laden medication and other less conventional options. Here we examine how neuroplasticity allows the healthy as well the impaired to benefit from cognitive training programs. We evaluate the evidence and consider whether brain training can be a stand-alone treatment or an adjunct to pharmacotherapy, outline promising future prospects, and highlight what training outcomes are plausible in line with available data. Future research would determine whether the field of brain training realizes its potential to revolutionize education and rehabilitation or withers away engulfed in controversy.
据称,这些产品可以安全有效地提高健康和疾病人群的认知表现,吸引了消费者和医疗保健从业者。在一个日益以健康为中心的社会中,这些应用构成了一个蓬勃发展的商业市场。然而,由于证据不足且缺乏科学严谨性,关于这种大脑训练的影响和持续时间的说法在很大程度上仍未得到证实。另一方面,至少有一些科学发现似乎支持针对注意力和工作记忆等高级大脑功能的训练的有效性和可持续性。在本文中,我们提供了认知训练方法的综合分析。具体来说,我们简要介绍了这些项目的相对优点和缺点,这些项目通常吸引那些必须在药物治疗和其他不太传统的选择之间做出选择的家长。在这里,我们研究了神经可塑性如何使健康和受损的人都能从认知训练计划中受益。我们评估了证据,并考虑了大脑训练是否可以作为独立治疗或药物治疗的辅助手段,概述了有前途的未来前景,并根据现有数据突出了训练结果的合理性。未来的研究将确定大脑训练领域是否能够实现其彻底改变教育和康复的潜力,还是会因争议而逐渐消失。